GoalUse survey and temperature data to explain where animals live, make predictions about changes in an ecosystem and choose reliable sources when researching a species.
New words
pitfall trap · a cup sunk into the ground so that small animals walking on the surface fall in; they are counted and then releasedmean · the total of the results divided by the number of resultsprediction · a statement of what you think will happen, with a reasonreliable source · information from experts who give evidence, which other sources also agree with
Explanation
Ecologists study an ecosystem by finding out where organisms live and by counting them. A pitfall trap is a cup with its rim level with the ground; small animals fall in, are counted and are put back where they were found. The traps are checked often so that the animals do not suffer or eat one another. One trap is not enough, so several are used and a mean is calculated, and a result far from the others is an anomaly that is checked or repeated. A thermometer can compare the temperature in different habitats, which helps to explain why animals choose them. The results are used to make and test predictions, for example about what would happen to other organisms if one species disappeared. When you research a species, check who wrote the information, whether it gives evidence, how old it is and whether the writer wants to sell something, and compare at least two sources.
Worked examples
Place
Trap 1
Trap 2
Trap 3
Mean
under shrubs
14
16
15
15
open sand
5
7
6
6
Beetles caught in three pitfall traps under shrubs and three on open sand. Mean under shrubs = (14 + 16 + 15) ÷ 3 = 15. Mean on open sand = (5 + 7 + 6) ÷ 3 = 6. More beetles live under the shrubs.
The temperature chart explains the survey. At midday the open sand is much hotter than the shade, and the burrow is the coolest place. This is why many animals shelter in burrows by day. The measurements were taken on one day, so the scientist should repeat them on other days to make the conclusion more reliable.
Source
Written by
Gives evidence?
How far to trust it
page selling desert holidays
a travel company
few facts, many promises
low, because it wants to sell
university biology department page
scientists
yes, with references
high
comment under a video
an unknown person
none
very low
Three sources about desert animals compared by a careful researcher.
Class activity
Two habitats in your own area, with an adult. Choose a garden, park or yard. Find two places that look different (for example the shade under a bush and a bare sunny patch). At the same time of day, place a thermometer on the ground in each place for three minutes and record the temperature (keep the bulb out of direct sunlight if you can). Look carefully, without touching, for small animals in each place and count them for five minutes each. Do not pick up unknown animals, do not touch stinging insects, stay with your adult and wash your hands afterwards. Put your results in a table. Which place was cooler? Which had more animals? Suggest why, and say what you would do to make your results more reliable.
Practice
1
Three pitfall traps on open sand catch 4, 6 and 19 beetles. Which result is anomalous and what is the mean of the other two?
Trap
Beetles
1
4
2
6
3
19
19 is anomalous because it is far from the others. The mean of 4 and 6 is (4 + 6) ÷ 2 = 5. The trap with 19 should be checked or the test repeated.
2
Predict what would happen to the beetles and the lizards if all the shrubs in an area were cleared. Use the lesson data in your answer.
There would be fewer beetles, because the traps under shrubs caught more and the shrub is food and shade. With fewer beetles the lizards would have less to eat, and the bare sand is too hot at midday, so their numbers would fall.
3
Look at the chart of the temperature of open sand and of a burrow through the day. When is the difference biggest, and why is a nocturnal animal not harmed by it?
The difference is biggest at 14:00 (about 29 °C). A nocturnal animal rests in the cool burrow in the hot afternoon and comes out when the sand has cooled in the evening and at night.
4
Omar finds two pages about the monitor lizard. One was written by a zoo to sell tickets; the other is by a university and lists its sources. Which should he trust more, and what should he do next?
He should trust the university page more, because it gives evidence and is not selling anything. He should still check the facts against a second independent source.