GoalExplain why many tiny air sacs are better than a few big ones, using a model and data.
New words
surface area · the size of the surface that is in contact with something elseanalogy · a comparison that helps us understand something unfamiliarmodel · a simple idea or object used to explain how something worksadapted · having features that suit a job
Explanation
Gases can only cross the surface of an air sac. Imagine two lungs with the same total volume: one has a few big sacs and the other has very many tiny ones. The tiny ones give a much larger surface area for the same volume, so more oxygen can diffuse into the blood each second. The human lungs have hundreds of millions of air sacs. Their total surface area is about the size of a badminton court. Scientists use models and analogies to study this. In every model, ask what each part stands for, what the model shows well and where it is not like the real thing. Data also helps: larger animals need more oxygen, and they have a larger area of air sacs.
Worked examples
1 big cube
8 small cubes
side
4 cm
2 cm
area of one cube
96 cm²
24 cm²
total area
96 cm²
192 cm²
Sara compares one big cube with eight small cubes that have the same total volume. The big cube has 6 faces of 4 cm × 4 cm. Eight small cubes of 2 cm sides have 6 faces of 2 cm × 2 cm each. The eight small cubes have twice the surface area of the big one.
Nodira draws a bar chart of data she found: the total surface area of the air sacs of four mammals (approximate values).
Part of the model
Stands for
crushed sugar or a whole cube
the surface for exchange
water
blood
time to dissolve
how fast the exchange happens
A model has limits. In a dissolving model the sugar is the oxygen and the water is the blood. It shows that a bigger surface lets a substance move in faster, but real lungs also have blood flowing past, which keeps the difference between air and blood large.
Class activity
Does surface area matter? With an adult, use two cups with the same volume of warm tap water (made by the adult and not boiling) and two sugar cubes. Put one cube in whole and the other cube crushed with the back of a spoon. Predict which dissolves first. Do not stir. Time how long each takes with a stopwatch, and repeat if you can. What is the variable you change? What do you keep the same? How does this model the air sacs? Write one limit of the model.
Practice
1
Two lungs hold the same total volume. Why does the lung with a huge number of tiny sacs take in oxygen faster than the lung with a few big bags?
Many small sacs have a much bigger total surface area, so more oxygen can diffuse into the blood each second and more carbon dioxide can leave.
2
Look at the bar chart of a person’s breaths each minute. What is the pattern, and give a reason for it.
The harder the activity, the more breaths each minute. Working muscles respire faster, so they need more oxygen and make more carbon dioxide, and the breathing system must supply and remove it faster.
3
A cube has sides of 3 cm. Cut into 27 cubes of 1 cm, how does the total surface area change? (The big cube has 6 × 9 = 54 cm².)
1 cube
27 cubes
side
3 cm
1 cm
total area
54 cm²
?
Each small cube has 6 × 1 = 6 cm², so 27 × 6 = 162 cm². The total surface area is 3 times larger.
4
In the sugar-cube investigation, a student gets 90 s for the whole cube and 25 s for the crushed cube. What conclusion matches the evidence, and why should he repeat it?
The crushed cube dissolved faster, so a larger surface area makes dissolving (and a model for exchange) faster. He should repeat to check the results are reliable and to spot any anomalous result.