GoalCompare wired and wireless connections and choose one for a situation, giving reasons.
New words
wired connection · devices joined by cableswireless connection · devices joined by radio waves, such as wi-fireliable · works well, with few breaks and errorssecure · protected from people who should not see or change the data
Explanation
A wired network uses cables. It is usually faster and more reliable, and it is more secure, because someone must be able to plug in to the cables. It costs more to set up, and it is harder to add a new device. A wireless network uses radio waves. It is cheaper to set up, and easy to add devices. It is usually slower, and walls and other radio waves can disturb it. It can be less secure, because anyone who learns the password could join. So a wireless network needs a strong password that is kept secret from everyone except a parent or carer. There is no single best choice, so you must look at what the people need.
Wired
Wireless
Speed
usually faster
usually slower
Reliability
more reliable
walls and radio waves can disturb
Security
harder to get into
password must be strong and secret
Adding devices
harder, needs a cable
easier, enter the password
Cost
more cables to buy
usually cheaper
Worked examples
Need
Wired or wireless?
Reason
private files
wired
harder for outsiders to reach
computers never move
wired
no need to move around
fast file sharing
wired
usually faster
An accountant’s office has six computers in one room. They hold clients’ private files and are rarely moved. Wired is a good choice: it is secure, fast and reliable, and the cables are short, so the cost is small.
Need
Wired or wireless?
Reason
guests move around
wireless
no cable needed
many different devices
wireless
easy to add devices
cheap to set up
wireless
one access point
A café wants guests to use their phones and laptops anywhere in the room. Wireless is the better choice: guests can join without cables, and the owner does not have to run a cable to every table. The owner must still keep the password for the staff network private.
Some networks use both. A family’s flat has a computer wired to the router for fast video calls, while phones and tablets use wi-fi so they can move around the flat.
Class activity
Choose and argue (with a partner, no computer). Read three cards. Card 1: a small clinic with 5 computers that hold patient records. Card 2: a market-stall league with 12 sellers moving around a square all day, sharing a price list. Card 3: a farm shop with a till and a card reader by the door, and a tablet used out in the yard. For each card, write wired, wireless or both. Give two reasons using the words speed, security, cost, reliability and moving devices. Take turns to disagree politely, then see if you can come to a decision together. Which reasons did you both agree on? What could you do better next time? If you have a computer or tablet, ask an adult to help you type your table.
Practice
1
Complete the table for a small architect’s studio. The computers hold clients’ private drawings, and the meeting room is used by visitors with phones.
Need
Wired or wireless?
clients’ private drawings must stay private
?
a meeting room for visitors’ phones
?
Wired is better for the drawings, because it is more secure and more reliable. Wireless could be used for visitors, because it is cheaper and easy to add devices.
2
A school hall wants a projector, a computer and a screen to be joined. All three stay on one stage for years. Which connection would you choose, and why?
Wired. The devices do not move, so cables are fine. A wired link is fast and reliable, with no interference from walls, which is good for a video.
3
Give two disadvantages of a wireless connection.
It is usually slower than a wired one. Radio waves can be disturbed by walls and other signals. It can be less secure if the password is weak or shared.
4
A pupil says, “Wireless is always better because there are no cables.” Do you agree? Give one reason for and one against.
Not always. For: easy to add devices and cheaper. Against: usually slower, can be disturbed and can be less secure, so wired may be better when speed or privacy matter.