GoalDecide which data is needed for a purpose, and say what can go wrong when data is missing or not needed.
New words
purpose · the reason why the data is collected and usedincomplete data · data with some items missingnecessary data · data that is really needed for the purpose; extra data is not necessary
Explanation
Before collecting data, ask what it is for. The purpose decides which data is needed. A swimming club that wants to arrange lanes needs each swimmer’s swimming level, age group and the days they can come. It does not need a favourite colour, because that does not change the lane plan. Collect enough data to do the job, but not extra. If important data is missing, the plan may go wrong. A swimmer with no level on the list might be placed in a lane that is too fast. Extra data also takes time to collect and store, and personal data needs permission and protection. Only ask for what you need, and say why you are asking.
Data about a swimmer
Needed for lane plans?
swimming level
yes
age group
yes
days they can come
yes
favourite colour
no
pet’s name
no
Worked examples
A club plans training lanes. These are fields it might collect. The first two are needed. The last two would not change the plan, so they are extra.
Missing data
Possible effect
swimming level
a beginner may be put in a fast lane, which is unsafe
days they can come
the swimmer is put in a session they cannot attend
age group
young swimmers could be mixed with much older ones
What could go wrong when needed data is missing? Each row shows a missing item and its effect on the lane plan.
Short form (needed data only)
Long form (needed + extra)
Time to fill in
short
long
Risk if the data is lost
low
higher, because more is stored
Permission needed
only for what is needed
for more personal data
Plan is just as good?
yes
yes
Why not collect everything “just in case”? Compare a short form with a long form for the same purpose.
Class activity
Plan the data (no computer). Your class is going to choose quiz-night teams. Write a list of every piece of data you could ask for, such as age, favourite subject, days free and shoe size. Circle the data that is needed to make fair teams, and cross out what is not needed. Choose the three most important items and write one reason for each. Then say what could go wrong if the most important item is missing. Compare with a partner. Remember that only invented data is used for practice, never real people’s details. If you have a computer or tablet, ask an adult to help you write your list in a word processor.
Practice
1
A football club wants to put each new player in a suitable age team. Which of these items are needed? (a) their age; (b) their favourite colour; (c) whether they have played in a team before; (d) their pet’s name.
Data
Needed?
(a) their age
?
(b) their favourite colour
?
(c) whether they have played in a team before
?
(d) their pet’s name
?
(a) and (c) are needed, because they decide which team is suitable. (b) and (d) are not needed.
2
A cycling club has no data about which riders can ride 20 km. What could go wrong when it plans the long ride?
Rider
Can ride 20 km?
Ana
yes
Ben
not known
Chen
yes
A rider who cannot ride 20 km might be put on the long ride and get tired or stuck far from home. The plan should be based on complete data.
3
Give two reasons why an organiser should not collect extra personal data.
It takes more time to collect and look after. It needs permission and protection, and more could be lost or misused. It also does not help the purpose.
4
A pupil says, “More data is always better.” Do you agree? Explain.
No. Data should be necessary and enough for the purpose. Extra data gives no benefit and adds time and risk. Missing needed data is the real problem.