GoalSay what a model and a simulator are, and give reasons why simulators are used.
New words
model · a simplified copy of something real, used to study it or to test ideassimulator · a computer model that people can use to practise or to see how a system would behavesimulate · to copy how a real system works, using a model
Explanation
A model is a simplified copy of something real. A toy bridge is a model, and so is a map. A simulator is a model that runs on a computer and reacts to what the user does. Learner drivers, ship captains and engineers use simulators to practise or to test ideas. There are good reasons. Simulators are safe, because a mistake cannot hurt anyone. They are cheaper than the real equipment. They are repeatable, so you can try the same situation again and again. They can also show things that are rare or very slow in real life. A simulator is only as good as its model. If the model leaves out something important, the results may not match real life.
Real system and its rulescopied into→Modelrun as→Simulator on a computerused by→User practises safely
Worked examples
Three jobs where a simulator helps people practise before the real thing. Each practice can be repeated, and a mistake harms nobody.
Simulator
Real road
Safety
no one can be hurt
mistakes can cause crashes
Cost
low, after it is built
fuel, a car and an instructor
Repeat the same junction?
yes, as often as you like
only when you drive there again
Bad weather or rare events?
can be switched on at any time
cannot be chosen
Why use a simulator? A comparison of a simulator and the real thing for a learner who is practising a hard road junction.
Included in the model
Left out of the model
weight of vehicles
rust over many years
length and shape of the bridge
a sudden earthquake
strength of the materials
the colour of the paint
A model is a simplification. A simulator of a bridge may model the weight of vehicles but leave out how rust slowly weakens the metal. Always ask what a model leaves out.
Class activity
Paper bridge test (no computer). Make a bridge from a folded sheet of paper between two piles of books. Place coins on it one at a time and count how many it holds before it sags. Write the number. Now change the design, for example by adding a fold, and test again. Compare the results in a table. This is a model: it is cheap, safe and repeatable. Say what it does not show about a real bridge. If you have a computer or tablet, ask an adult to show you a picture of a bridge-testing simulator.
Practice
1
Is a map a model or a simulator? Explain.
A map is a model, because it is a simplified copy of a real place. It is not a simulator, because it does not react to what the user does.
2
Give three reasons why trainee drivers use a driving simulator before driving on a real road.
It is safe, because mistakes cannot hurt anyone. It is cheaper than a real car and instructor. It is repeatable, so the same hard situation can be practised again and again.
3
A sailing trainer says: “The simulator is exactly the same as sailing.” Do you agree? Explain.
real boatcopied by→modelgives→?
No. The simulator is a model, and it leaves some things out, such as the real feel of wind and waves and some rare events. It copies the most important parts well, but it cannot be exactly the same.
4
For which of these is a simulator most useful, and why? (a) learning to tie your shoelaces; (b) practising how to steer a ship into a busy harbour; (c) writing your name.
Job
Simulator useful?
(a) tie your shoelaces
?
(b) steer a ship into a busy harbour
?
(c) write your name
?
(b). Practising in a real ship in a busy harbour would be dangerous and expensive. The other two can be practised safely with the real thing.