GoalRepeat measurements, work out a mean, spot an anomalous result and write a conclusion that matches the evidence.
New words
mean · a type of average: add the results and divide by how many there areanomalous result · a result that does not fit the patternrepeat · to do the same test again to check the resultsconclusion · what the results tell you, linked back to the question
Explanation
One test can be wrong, so scientists repeat their measurements. They then work out a mean by adding the results and dividing by how many there are. A result that does not fit the pattern is called an anomalous result. It may come from a mistake, such as an extra spoon or a spill. An anomalous result should be checked, repeated and left out of the mean, with a reason. A conclusion should say what the results show about the question, using the numbers. The evidence is stronger when the measurements are repeated and the test is fair.
Worked examples
Liquid
Try 1
Try 2
Try 3
vinegar
12
11
13
lemon juice
7
8
6
half-strength vinegar
6
15
7
Results of Omar and Lola’s test: the number of spoons of bicarbonate solution needed for each liquid in three tries. One result does not fit the others.
The 15 is anomalous. With it, the mean for the half-strength vinegar is (6 + 15 + 7) ÷ 3 ≈ 9.3. Without it, the mean is (6 + 7) ÷ 2 = 6.5. They should repeat the test and not use 15.
Conclusion: the half-strength vinegar (mean 6.5 spoons) needed about half as much alkali as the full-strength vinegar (mean 12 spoons). This supports the prediction that less acid needs less alkali.
Class activity
Mean practice (with a family member): do a quick investigation. Drop a table-tennis ball, a ball of paper or a small toy from the same height onto a floor three times, and count how many bounces or how many seconds it moves. Record your three results in a table and work out the mean. Now ask the family member to name which result would be anomalous if one of your counts were very different. Write a sentence about whether you should include it in the mean and why.
Practice
1
Three tries needed 8, 9 and 7 spoons. Work out the mean.
(8 + 9 + 7) ÷ 3 = 8 spoons.
2
A table shows 14, 15 and 5 spoons for three tries of the same test. Which result is anomalous, and what should the scientist do?
Try 1
Try 2
Try 3
14
15
5
5 is anomalous. Check for a mistake, repeat the test and leave 5 out of the mean if it was a mistake.
3
Why is the evidence from three repeats of a test better than the evidence from one test?
If the repeats agree, we can trust the result more. A single result could be wrong because of a mistake.
4
Write a conclusion for this bar chart (mean spoons).
Liquid A needed the most bicarbonate solution (12 spoons), so it contains the most acid of the three.