GoalTurn a vague question about acids and alkalis into one that can be tested, and make a prediction.
New words
testable question · a question that an investigation can answer by measuring or observingvariable · something that can change in an investigationprediction · a statement of what you think will happen, with a reasonevidence · the results and observations that support or reject an idea
Explanation
Scientists ask questions, but not every question can be tested. A question such as ‘Which drink is healthiest?’ is vague, because ‘healthiest’ could mean least sugar, most vitamins or least acid. A testable question says what is changed and what is measured. For example: ‘Which of three soap solutions turns red cabbage juice the bluest?’ Before the test, a scientist makes a prediction and gives a reason, for example from what is known about alkalis. The things that can change in an investigation are called variables. The results are then used as evidence to support or reject the prediction.
Worked examples
Vague question
Testable question
Which juice is the sourest?
Which of three clear drinks turns red cabbage juice the reddest?
Which soap is best?
Which of three soap solutions turns the juice the bluest?
Which acid is the strongest?
How many spoons of bicarbonate solution does it take to neutralise 50 mL of each of three acids?
Each vague question can be reworded so that something can be measured or observed.
Kenji predicts that the vinegar will need more bicarbonate solution than the same vinegar mixed with an equal amount of water. His reason: the mixed one has less acid in it.
A scientist using universal indicator decides in advance that the end point is the green colour, which means pH 7. A clear end point makes the investigation precise.
Class activity
Question-maker (with an adult): choose two or three clear liquids from the kitchen, for example vinegar, lemon juice and soapy water. An adult prepares red cabbage juice. Write a vague question about them, such as ‘Which is strongest?’. Then reword it so that you could test it with the cabbage juice, saying what you would change and what you would observe. Write a prediction with a reason. With an adult, put a spoonful of each liquid in a separate clear cup, add the same amount of cabbage juice and check your prediction. Do not taste anything; wash your hands afterwards.
Practice
1
Why can ‘Which fruit juice is the most acidic?’ be tested, while ‘Which fruit juice is nicest?’ cannot?
Acidity can be measured, for example with an indicator or by counting spoons of an alkali needed to neutralise the same volume of each juice. ‘Nicest’ is an opinion, so different people would give different answers.
2
Reword this into a testable question: ‘Which drink has the most acid?’
For example: ‘Which of three clear drinks needs the most spoons of bicarbonate solution to turn the cabbage juice purple?’
3
Ana predicts that lemon juice will turn red cabbage juice pink. What would she need to see for her prediction to be supported, and what is her reason likely to be?
The juice would turn pink or red. Her reason: lemon juice is an acid, and acids turn the cabbage juice pink or red.
4
At what colour do scientists stop adding acid when they use universal indicator and want a neutral solution?