GoalDescribe how scientists think the Solar System formed, and how evidence and models support a hypothesis.
New words
nebula · a huge cloud of dust and gas in spacehypothesis · an idea that can be tested with evidenceevidence · facts from observations or experiments that support an ideamodel · a way of showing something that is hard to observe, with some limits
Explanation
Nobody was there to watch the Solar System form, so scientists use evidence and models. They see young stars forming in other nebulae, some with flat discs of dust around them. They think our Sun and planets were made in the same way, from a nebula. As particles stick together, the lump grows, its mass rises and its gravity gets stronger, so it attracts even more. A ball that grows past a certain size gets hot enough to become a star, and smaller balls become planets. Some facts agree with this idea. All the planets go round the Sun in the same direction, and their paths lie in one flat layer, like marbles rolling round a flat tray. But Venus spins the opposite way to most planets, and this fact does not fit. So the hypothesis fits most of the evidence, but not all of it.
cloud of dust and gas→gravity pulls particles together→a big ball forms: a star→smaller balls: planets
Worked examples
Fact
Supports or contradicts?
All planets orbit the Sun in the same direction
supports
All planets orbit in one flat plane
supports
Venus spins the opposite way to most planets
seems to contradict
Nodira finds a fact in each row and decides whether it supports the hypothesis that the planets formed from a spinning disc. Most agree, but one is the odd one out.
A mass of dust grows as it attracts more dust. The bigger it gets, the stronger its gravity. This is why the process speeds up as the ball grows.
real cloud: millions of years→computer model: runs in hours→prediction: a star with planets
Scientists use a computer model because the real process takes millions of years, and nobody can repeat it in a laboratory. One limit is that the model is only as good as the physics put into it.
Class activity
Growing-clump model (with an adult): spread a thin layer of dry rice or lentils on a tray. Roll a small ball of play dough across it again and again. Watch the ball pick up grains and grow. Now think: in what way is this like a clump of dust growing in a nebula? In what way is it different? (Hint: what makes the play dough pick things up, and what made real dust clump together?) This is a model, so write down one thing it shows well and one limit.
Practice
1
What is a nebula, and what is it made of?
A huge cloud in space made of dust and gas.
2
Explain why a growing ball of dust attracts more and more dust.
As more dust joins, its mass gets bigger, so its gravity gets stronger and it pulls in even more dust.
3
Kenji says: ‘Venus spins the wrong way, so the whole idea of the planets forming from one spinning disc must be wrong.’ Do you agree? Explain.
No. The idea fits most of the evidence (same direction of orbit, one flat layer, discs seen round young stars). One fact that does not fit means scientists look for more evidence or improve the idea, for example by asking whether something later changed Venus’s spin.
4
Nobody saw the Solar System form. Name two kinds of evidence or tools that scientists use to learn about it.
Any two of: watching new stars form in other nebulae; seeing flat discs of dust round young stars; facts such as the planets orbiting in the same direction and the same plane; computer models.