GoalPlan an investigation by naming the variable that is changed, the one that is measured and those kept the same.
New words
independent variable · the variable that you changedependent variable · the variable that you measurecontrol variable · a variable you keep the same to make the test fairmodel · something simpler used to stand for the real thing
Explanation
To plan an investigation, first decide what you will change, what you will measure and what you will keep the same. The variable you change is the independent variable. The variable you measure is the dependent variable. All the others are control variables and must be kept the same, or the test is not fair. Scientists often test ideas on a model first. A bucket of slightly acidic water can stand in for an acid lake, because it is safer and easier to measure. A model has limits, since a real lake is huge, flows and is full of living things. Write a method, a list of equipment, safety steps and a results table before you start.
question→prediction→plan→results→conclusion
Worked examples
Kind of variable
In this test
changed (independent)
which liquid is tested
measured (dependent)
number of spoons until the colour changes
kept the same (control)
volume of liquid, drops of juice, size of spoon, stirring
Tom and Aisha compare how many spoons of bicarbonate solution neutralise three liquids. Each variable has a job in the plan.
The three beakers hold the same volume of liquid at the start. If one beaker held more, it would need more spoons and the test would not be fair.
Real lake
Model: a bucket of water
contains fish and plants
yes
no
very large, with flowing water
yes
no
easy to test and measure
no
yes
A bucket of slightly acidic water is a model of an acid lake. It shows that an alkali can neutralise acid, but it has no fish or plants, no flowing water and is tiny, which are limits of the model.
Class activity
Fair test plan (with an adult): you will compare how many teaspoons of bicarbonate solution (a teaspoon of bicarbonate of soda stirred into a cup of water) are needed to turn the same amount of two different liquids from pink to purple, using red cabbage juice made by the adult. The adult measures the liquids and does the stirring. Write the independent variable, the dependent variable and at least four control variables. Then predict which liquid will need more spoons. Carry out the test with the adult and record your results in a table. Do not taste the liquids. Wash your hands afterwards.
Practice
1
In the test with the cups and bicarbonate solution, which variable do you change and which do you measure?
You change the liquid being tested. You measure the number of spoons of bicarbonate solution needed.
2
Name four things you must keep the same so that the test is fair.
For example: the volume of each liquid, the number of drops of cabbage juice, the size of the spoon and the way you stir.
3
One of the three beakers contains more liquid than the others. Why is that a problem?
It would probably need more spoons of bicarbonate solution just because there is more liquid, so we could not compare the liquids fairly.
4
Why might scientists try lime on a bucket of acidic water before they treat a real lake? Name one limit of the bucket model.
It is safer, cheaper and easier to measure. One limit: a real lake is much bigger, it flows, and it has fish and plants in it, but the bucket does not.