GoalUse the particle model to explain why alloys are harder than pure metals, and name the limits of the model.
New words
atom · the smallest part of an element that can exist on its ownlayer · one row or sheet of particlesdisrupt · upset a pattern so that it no longer works smoothlymodel · an idea or picture that helps us to explain something
Explanation
Atoms in a pure metal are one size and sit in tidy layers. When a force pushes on the metal, one layer slips over the next with little effort. That is why a pure metal is soft, can be hammered (malleable) and can be drawn into wire (ductile). In an alloy, atoms of another element, of a different size, are mixed in. These atoms spoil the neat pattern, so the layers catch on each other and cannot slip easily. The alloy is therefore harder and stronger. All this is a model: real atoms are not hard balls, and a drawing shows only a flat slice. Even so, it explains why steel is harder than pure iron and bronze is harder than copper.
Worked examples
Nodira models a pure metal with identical peas in a tray. The rows slide when she pushes a ruler through. This is like a pure metal being bent.
She now puts a few large beans among the peas. The ruler sticks and the layers do not slide easily. This is like an alloy. One limit of the model is that real atoms are not hard balls.
A metalworker hits a lump of copper and a lump of bronze with the same hammer. The copper dents easily but the bronze resists. In bronze the larger tin atoms stop the layers of copper atoms slipping.
Class activity
Model of a metal and an alloy (with an adult, in a shallow tray or lid): half-fill a tray with dried peas or lentils of the same size. Gently push a ruler or card through the middle and see how the rows slide. Now mix in a few large beans or marbles and try again. Describe what changes. Which tray is like the alloy? What does a pea stand for? Name two things the model does not show. Clear up all the food afterwards and do not eat it.
Practice
1
Describe the arrangement of atoms in the pure metal in the picture.
The atoms are one size and lie in tidy, regular layers.
2
Explain why a pure metal can be hammered into shape.
When a force acts, the layers of atoms slide over each other easily, so the shape changes without breaking.
3
A bicycle maker uses an aluminium alloy, not pure aluminium. Use the model to explain why the alloy is stronger.
Pure aluminium
Aluminium alloy
atoms
one size
two sizes mixed
layers
?
?
The other metal’s atoms are a different size. They disrupt the layers of aluminium atoms, so the layers cannot slide easily.
4
Give one way the pea-and-bean model is like a real alloy and one way it is not.
Like: big pieces stop the layers sliding. Not like: real atoms are not hard balls, and the model shows only two dimensions.