GoalUse observations and evidence to judge whether organisms belong to the same species, and name the limits of the definition.
New words
evidence · facts from observation or testsconclusion · what the evidence tells uscompare · look for similarities and differencesconserve · protect living things and where they live
Explanation
A good scientist collects evidence before making a conclusion. First, observe the organisms closely and write a table of similarities and differences. Then look at the key test: do they breed together, and can their young have young? Checking many pairs gives stronger evidence than checking one. Sometimes scientists disagree, for example about whether a rare bird is a separate species, and the answer can affect whether it is protected. The species idea has limits, because organisms that never meet, or that are extinct, cannot be tested. So scientists use all the evidence they can find. Their conclusions can change when new evidence appears.
Step
What the scientist does
1
observe and describe each organism
2
compare: list similarities and differences
3
see whether they reproduce together
4
check whether the young are fertile
5
conclude, using all the evidence
Worked examples
Omar watched the nests of two kinds of finch for a whole season. He never found a pair made of one of each kind. This evidence suggests they are different species.
Leo’s results show how many pairs were of each type. All pairs were of the same kind. Checking more pairs would make the evidence stronger.
Two scientists disagree. One says there are 20 species of frog in a pond area, the other says 10. Which kind of evidence would help them settle it?
Class activity
Compare two kinds of fruit or seed (with an adult): take two similar items, for example two kinds of apple or two kinds of bean. Write five similarities and at least two differences in a table. Then answer: could these be the same species? What would a scientist do to be sure? (You cannot test this with fruit, so say what you would observe if they were living animals or plants.) Wash your hands afterwards.
Practice
1
Explain the steps a scientist might follow to decide whether two kinds of lizard are different species.
Observe and compare them, then see whether they reproduce together, and check if the young are fertile. Watch many pairs, and use all the evidence.
2
Which gives stronger evidence: watching one pair of birds or 40 pairs? Why?
40 pairs, because a larger set of observations is more reliable and less likely to be a chance result.
3
Why can the ‘fertile offspring’ test not be used for a fossil?
The animal is extinct, so no pairs can be watched breeding.
4
A conclusion might change later. Give one reason why that is acceptable in science.
Year
What scientists thought
2000
one species
2020
two species (new evidence)
New evidence may be found. Scientists change their ideas when the evidence changes.