GoalUse reproduction and fertile offspring to decide whether organisms belong to the same species.
New words
offspring · the young made when organisms reproducefertile · able to produce offspringinfertile · not able to produce offspringreproduce · make young
Explanation
To be sure whether two organisms are one species, scientists ask whether they can breed together and have young that can also breed. Two goats have a kid that grows up and later has kids of its own, so goats are one species. Different species do not usually breed together. Very rarely, in a farm or zoo, two species do produce young. A zebra and a donkey can have a young animal called a zonkey. A zonkey is healthy, but it is infertile, so it cannot have young of its own. Because of this, zebras and donkeys are two different species. The test has limits: we cannot try it on extinct animals or on organisms that never meet.
Worked examples
A male and female goat have a kid. It grows up and has kids of its own, and so do they. All the young are fertile, so the parents are one species.
Pair
Can they reproduce?
Offspring fertile?
Same species?
dog and dog
yes
yes
yes
zebra and donkey
rarely
no (zonkey)
no
cat and goat
no
–
no
Tom’s table sums up three pairs. Only the pair in row 1 are the same species.
Nodira says two flowers look the same, so they must be the same species. Is she right? Not necessarily. Looks are only the first clue. Scientists would test if they make fertile offspring.
Class activity
Species detectives (paper game): write ten animal names on cards (for example horse, donkey, dog, wolf, cat, lion). Pair them up. For each pair, use what you know or can find in a book to guess: do they usually reproduce? are the young fertile? Make a table with the headings Pair, Same species?, Evidence. Which pair was hardest? What further evidence would help? (Do not touch real animals you do not know.)
Practice
1
What does ‘fertile’ mean?
Able to produce offspring.
2
A zonkey is the young of a zebra and a donkey. Explain why zebras and donkeys are different species.
Zonkeys are infertile, so zebras and donkeys cannot produce fertile offspring together.
3
Two beetles look very similar but never breed together in the wild. What might scientists conclude?
They may be two different species, although more evidence would make them surer.
4
Fill the gaps: ‘Members of one species can breed with each other, and their young are ______, so they can have ______ of their own.’