GoalUse properties to choose a way to separate a mixture, and read results and models critically.
New words
property · a feature, such as being magnetic or dissolving, that can help to separate substancesmodel · a picture or idea that helps to explain something and has limitsevidence · facts from observations or measurements that support an ideaanomalous result · a result that does not fit the pattern
Explanation
To separate a mixture, scientists look for a property that is different in each part. Iron is magnetic and sulfur is not, so a magnet works. Sand does not dissolve in water but salt does, so we can filter the sand out and let the water evaporate to get the salt back. In a mixture, the different kinds of particle are mixed but not bonded. In a compound, the particles of different elements are bonded together into new particles. When we plan an investigation we say what we change, what we measure and what we keep the same. When we study results, we look for an anomalous result and decide whether to repeat the test.
mixture of salt and sand→add water and stir (salt dissolves)→filter out the sand→leave the water to evaporate (salt is left)
Worked examples
Mixture
Magnet picked something out?
A: paperclips and sugar
yes
B: salt and rice
no
C: iron filings and sand
yes
Ben tests three mixtures with a magnet. The magnet pulled something out of mixtures A and C but not B. So A and C each contain a magnetic substance such as iron. B does not.
Water temperature (°C)
Time to dissolve (s)
10
80
20
62
30
48
40
90
50
25
Yuki dissolves a spoonful of salt in the same volume of water at different temperatures. The salt dissolves in every case. The 40 °C result is much too long for the pattern. It could be an anomalous result. She should repeat that test.
Mixture
Compound
Atoms of different elements joined?
no
yes
Properties
each part keeps its own
new, different
Separating
easy: physical way
hard: chemical change
Compare a mixture with a compound. The mixture has two kinds of particle that are not joined. The compound has particles in which unlike atoms are bonded.
Class activity
Separate the mixture (with an adult): an adult mixes a spoon of salt and a spoon of sand in a cup of cool water and stirs. Pour it through a coffee filter into a bowl. What stays in the filter? What went through? Pour the clear liquid into a shallow dish and leave it in a warm place for several days. Predict what will be left. Draw labelled boxes for each stage. Which properties of salt and sand did you use? Wash your hands afterwards.
Practice
1
Which property would you use to separate each mixture? (a) iron nails and plastic beads (b) sand and salt
(a) Iron is magnetic, so use a magnet. (b) Salt dissolves in water but sand does not, so add water, filter, then evaporate the water.
2
Leo times how long a sugar cube takes to dissolve in water at four temperatures. Which result looks anomalous? What should he do about it?
Water temperature (°C)
Time to dissolve (s)
10
120
20
70
30
95
40
35
The 95 s at 30 °C. The time should keep falling as the water gets warmer, but this one is longer than the one at 20 °C. He should repeat the test at that temperature.
3
Why is a picture of coloured balls only a model of a compound? Name one limit.
Real atoms are not coloured balls and are far too small to see. The picture helps us show which atoms are joined, but it does not show their real size or what they are really like.
4
Sam says: ‘Sea water must be a compound because I can’t see the salt.’ Is he right? What would you say to him?
No. Sea water is a mixture. The salt is dissolved in water but not bonded to it. You could get it back by evaporating the water, which shows they are only mixed.