GoalUse a role-play model of particles, judge its strengths and limits, and use data to work out the state of a substance.
New words
model · a way of showing how something worksstrength · a good point about a modellimit · something a model gets wrongroom temperature · about 20 °C
Explanation
Scientists use models to show things that are too small to see. In a class model each person is a particle. To show a solid, stand close in rows and wobble on the spot. To melt it, wobble more and start to move past each other while keeping in touch. To boil the liquid, move faster until some people break away and travel freely. The model shows how particles are arranged and move, but it has limits: real particles are far smaller than people, there are countless of them and they are not alive. We can also use data. A substance is a liquid if its temperature is above its melting point and below its boiling point. It is a solid below its melting point and a gas above its boiling point.
Worked examples
Part of the model
Good because
Weak because
people are particles
shows arrangement and movement
people are huge and alive
moving faster to show heating
shows more energy means faster movement
real particles are not people with a plan
holding hands for a solid
shows forces
real forces are not hands
Lola’s class model. Which parts of the model are good and which are weak?
Substance
Melting point (°C)
Boiling point (°C)
water
0
100
ethanol
−114
78
iron
1538
2862
Using data: ethanol melts at −114 °C and boils at 78 °C. At a room temperature of 20 °C it is above the melting point and below the boiling point, so ethanol is a liquid.
−183 °C: oxygen boils→20 °C: room→oxygen is a gas
Oxygen has a boiling point of −183 °C. Room temperature is far above this, so oxygen is a gas at room temperature.
Class activity
Class model at home (with family): you are the particles. Show a solid, then slowly heat it by wobbling and moving more, melt, then let one person leave as a gas. Then cool it again. Ask someone to watch and judge your model: what did you show well and what did you get wrong? Afterwards, write down two limits. Balloon test with an adult: blow up a balloon, put it on the neck of a bottle, and stand the bottle in a bowl of warm (not hot) tap water that the adult pours. Watch the balloon. What happens? What do the air particles do?
Practice
1
Name one strength and one limit of the human particle model.
Strength: shows the arrangement and movement of particles in each state. Limit: people are far bigger than particles, can decide what to do, and do not show forces.
2
Use the data to say whether each substance is solid, liquid or gas at room temperature (20 °C).
Substance
Melting point (°C)
Boiling point (°C)
water
0
100
iron
1538
2862
nitrogen
−210
−196
Water: liquid. Iron: solid. Nitrogen: gas. (Nitrogen boils at −196 °C, which is far below 20 °C.)
3
Candle wax melts at about 55 °C. What state is it at 40 °C, and what state at 70 °C?
Solid at 40 °C and liquid at 70 °C.
4
A balloon on a bottle in warm water gets bigger. Use particle ideas to explain.
The air in the bottle is heated. Its particles gain energy, move faster and take up more space, so they push into the balloon and make it bigger.