GoalDecide whether a change is chemical or physical by using several clues, and explain why one clue alone may not be enough.
New words
physical change · a change in which no new substance is made, such as meltingchemical change · a change in which a new substance is madeevidence · clues and measurements that support a decisionirreversible · cannot easily be changed back
Explanation
A physical change does not make a new substance. Melting ice, dissolving salt and boiling water are physical changes, and they can usually be reversed. A chemical change makes a new substance, and it is usually hard to reverse. To decide, scientists collect evidence and look for several clues. One clue alone can mislead you. Boiling water makes bubbles, but they are only water vapour, so no new substance is made. Heating a pancake makes a new brown substance, so it is chemical. We should always say which clues support the decision.
Physical change
Chemical change
no new substance
a new substance is made
often easy to reverse
usually hard to reverse
melting, dissolving, boiling
burning, rusting, cooking
Worked examples
Leo sorts changes into two groups, using clues.
Water boiling in a pan has bubbles, but the bubbles are water vapour, so it is a physical change. If the water cooled again it would be water again.
Clue
What it suggests
the smell changes
a new substance
the milk turns lumpy
a new substance
it cannot change back
a chemical change
Milk left too long turns sour and smells different. A new substance has formed, and it will not change back, so it is a chemical change.
Class activity
Change detective (with an adult): collect examples in the kitchen, watching only. For each one, write physical or chemical and give two clues: ice melting, sugar dissolving in a cup of tea, bread being toasted by the adult, a banana turning brown, butter softening, a piece of fruit left in a bowl. Use a table with three columns: change, clues, physical or chemical. The adult does all the heating. Which changes could be reversed?
Practice
1
Sort these into physical or chemical change: salt dissolving in water, a nail rusting, ice melting, bread toasting.
Physical: salt dissolving, ice melting. Chemical: a nail rusting, bread toasting.
2
Tom says, ‘Water in a pan makes bubbles when it boils, so a chemical reaction has happened.’ Is he right?
No. The bubbles are water vapour and no new substance is made, so it is a physical change.
3
A candle is lit by an adult. The wax near the flame melts and the wick burns. Which part of this is a physical change and which a chemical change?
The wax melting is physical. The wick and the wax vapour burning is chemical because new substances are made.
4
Why should you use several clues to decide whether a change is chemical?
One clue can be misleading, like bubbles from boiling. Several clues give stronger evidence of a new substance.