GoalJoin the ideas about decomposers and nutrients, record results in a table, calculate a mean and decide whether the evidence is enough for a conclusion.
New words
mean · the total of all the values divided by the number of valuesevidence · the results that support an idearepeat · to do a measurement again, so that you can trust the resultanomalous · a result that does not fit the pattern
Explanation
Mia grows ten bean plants in matching pots. Five get crumbly compost made from vegetable peelings and five get plain soil. After eight weeks she weighs the beans from each plant and puts the results in a table. She then works out the mean of each group: add up the values and divide by the number of plants. If the mean is bigger for the compost, the evidence supports the idea that decomposers help plants. But five plants is a small sample, and one odd result can change a mean a lot. To be more sure, she should use more plants, repeat the test, and keep water and light the same. The compost helps because decomposers have set nutrients free from the dead plant material.
Beans per plant
Plant 1
Plant 2
Plant 3
Plant 4
Plant 5
with compost (g)
42
38
45
40
35
plain soil (g)
30
27
33
29
31
Worked examples
With compost: 42 + 38 + 45 + 40 + 35 = 200, and 200 ÷ 5 = 40 g. For plain soil the total is 150, so the mean is 30 g.
Good about the test
Could be better
clear table
only 5 plants in each group
same kind of bean and pot
only one test
means calculated
other differences possible
Is the evidence enough? The means agree with the idea, but the sample is small. One odd, anomalous value could shift a mean, so more plants make the result more reliable.
Who or what
Job
decomposers
break down dead material
nutrients
released into the soil
plants
take the nutrients up and grow
Joining the ideas: each part of the chain does a job.
Class activity
With an adult, collect data at home. Fill two pots with the same plain soil and add a spoonful of compost to only one of them. Plant five bean or cress seeds in each pot, give both the same water and light, and predict which will grow taller. Measure the height of each seedling every two or three days for two weeks and put the results in a table. Calculate the mean height of each group at the end and write a conclusion that uses your numbers. Wash your hands after touching soil or compost.
Practice
1
Calculate the mean mass of beans from five plants grown with only water: 18, 22, 20, 25 and 15 g.
Plant
1
2
3
4
5
mass of beans (g)
18
22
20
25
15
(18 + 22 + 20 + 25 + 15) ÷ 5 = 100 ÷ 5 = 20 g.
2
Another gardener weighs the beans from four compost plants: 41, 43, 12 and 40 g. Which value looks anomalous? What should she do?
12 g looks anomalous. She should check the weighing and look at that plant, then repeat the measurement if she can.
3
Why is it important that the plants near the compost and away from it get the same amount of water?
So that the test is fair. If the water differed, the water could explain the difference instead of the compost.
4
Mia’s means are 40 g with compost and 30 g without. Write a conclusion and say how sure you are.
The plants with compost gave more beans on average, so the evidence supports the idea. We cannot be certain, because only five plants were in each group; more plants and repeats would make it stronger.