GoalPlan and carry out a safe pH investigation of everyday liquids, record results in a table and draw a conclusion.
New words
variable · something that can change in an investigationanomalous result · a result that does not fit the patternconclusion · what the results tell usreliable · likely to give the same result if repeated
Explanation
This safe investigation finds out which everyday liquids are acids and which are alkalis, and an adult does all the preparing and pouring. We change the liquid we test (the independent variable) and we measure the indicator colour, which gives the pH (the dependent variable). For a fair test we keep the amount of liquid, the amount of indicator and the type of cup the same, and we use a clean cup each time. We predict first, record the colours in a table and read the pH from a colour chart. We never taste a test liquid. A result that does not fit the pattern is anomalous, so we repeat that test. Our conclusion must match the results, and we can suggest how to make the investigation more reliable, for example by repeating each test three times.
Variable
In this test
independent (change)
the liquid tested
dependent (measure)
indicator colour and pH
control (keep the same)
amount of liquid and indicator, clean cups
Worked examples
Liquid
Prediction
Colour
pH (about)
Type
tomato juice
acid
pink
4
acid
milk
neutral
purple
6–7
almost neutral
tap water
neutral
purple
7
neutral
baking soda in water
alkali
green
9
alkali
Omar predicted that tomato juice would be an acid and that baking soda in water would be an alkali. His red cabbage results agree. Milk is almost neutral.
Ben tests tap water three times and gets green, green and yellow. The yellow does not fit, so it is an anomalous result. He repeats the test and gets green again. He likely used a dirty cup the first time.
Result
Conclusion
lemon juice pH 2, vinegar pH 3
both are acids; lemon juice is stronger
water pH 7
water is neutral
soap solution pH 9
soap solution is a weak alkali
Aisha writes her conclusion. It matches her results and says what she is surest about.
Class activity
pH investigation (an adult prepares everything; use clear plastic cups, red cabbage juice from last lesson or universal indicator paper): test six liquids: apple juice, milk, tap water, sparkling water, bicarbonate of soda dissolved in water, and a little soap in water. Do not use cleaning products or any chemical bottle, and never mix the liquids together. Write a prediction for each. Add the same amount of indicator to each. Record the colours and use a colour chart to give a pH. Draw a bar chart. Which was the most acidic? Which was the most alkaline? Did any result surprise you? Wash your hands.
Practice
1
Name the independent variable and the dependent variable in the pH investigation.
Independent: the liquid tested. Dependent: the indicator colour (pH).
2
Give two control variables for this test.
Any two: same amount of liquid, same amount of indicator, same type of cup, clean cups.
3
From the results, which liquids are acids, and which is the strongest? Which is an alkali?
Liquid
pH
tomato juice
4
milk
6
tap water
7
soapy water
9
Tomato juice and milk are acids (weak ones); tomato juice is the strongest (pH 4). Soapy water is the alkali.
4
A student tests soapy water four times and gets pH 9, 9, 2 and 9. What should she do about the pH 2?
Treat it as an anomalous result, check for a mistake such as a dirty cup, and repeat the test.