GoalPlan and carry out tests to decide whether a material is a metal or a non-metal, and say how reliable the tests are.
New words
test · a way of finding out something using observation or measurementcircuit · a complete loop that lets an electric current flowreliable · can be trusted because it gives the same result when repeateddistinguish · tell apart
Explanation
To tell a metal from a non-metal, use several tests rather than one. Look at the surface, tap the material to hear whether it rings, and see whether it bends or snaps. Feel whether it seems cold to the touch, because metals carry heat away from your hand. Finally, check whether it lets electricity through: an adult builds a circuit with a small cell and a bulb, leaving a gap, and the material is put in the gap. If the bulb lights, the material is a conductor. Every test has limits: a magnet finds only magnetic metals, a dull surface may be a tarnished metal, and glass can ring. So we look for a pattern across all the tests.
Worked examples
Item
Shiny?
Rings?
Bulb lights?
Metal?
key
yes
yes
yes
metal
wooden stick
no
no
no
non-metal
foil
yes
no
yes
metal
Sara tests three items and records the results. The key passes every test for a metal. Foil does not ring, but it is shiny and the bulb lights, so it is still a metal. A test that gives the same answer for every item, such as ‘is it solid?’, does not help to tell them apart.
Kenji puts a coin in the gap and the bulb lights. The coin conducts electricity, so it is probably a metal. He also checks that it is shiny and does not shatter before he decides.
Aisha tests plastic in the gap. The bulb stays off, so plastic does not conduct electricity. It is an insulator.
Class activity
Conductor test (an adult builds the circuit and handles the cell and bulb; use only a small cell, never a plug socket): with an adult, join a small cell, a bulb and wires, with a gap. Predict first, then place each of ten items in the gap: coin, paper clip, key, plastic spoon, wooden stick, rubber band, foil, cork, chalk, eraser. Record in a table. Do the same items sort into the same groups as your other tests (shine, ring, bend)? Which test was the best at telling metal from non-metal? Which one was least useful?
Practice
1
In a circuit test, the bulb does not light when a material is in the gap. What can you conclude?
The material does not conduct electricity, so it is probably a non-metal (an insulator).
2
Give one reason why a magnet is not a good test for ‘is it a metal?’
Only a few metals (iron, steel, nickel, cobalt) are magnetic, so most metals would be missed.
3
What does the circuit test show for a paper clip, which is in the gap? Explain.
The bulb lights, because the paper clip is a metal and conducts electricity.
4
A silver-coloured material rings when hit, bends without breaking and lights the bulb, but a magnet does not pick it up. Is it a metal? Give your reasons.
Test
Result
shiny?
yes
rings when hit?
yes
bends?
yes, without breaking
bulb lights?
yes
magnet?
not picked up
Yes. It is shiny, sonorous, bendy and a conductor. Many metals, such as copper and aluminium, are not magnetic.