GoalConstruct a key for a set of organisms, test it with someone else and improve it.
New words
construct · build or maketest · try something out to see whether it worksimprove · make betterfeedback · comments from other people to help you improve
Explanation
To build a key, start with the group you want to name, for example four fruits. First find a feature that splits the group in two. Then split one of the small groups again, and repeat until every organism is alone. Four organisms need three questions, and six need five, because each question splits just one group in two. Choose features that anyone can check by looking, such as ‘Does it have a shell?’, and avoid opinions and vague words like ‘big’. Ask a friend to try your key. If they get stuck or get a wrong name, listen to their feedback, change your questions and test again.
pick a feature that splits the group in two→split each part again→stop when each has one name→test it on a friend and improve
Worked examples
Mia’s key for four fruits. Three questions are enough for four fruits.
Before
After
Is it big?
Does it have a thick peel you remove?
Is it a nice colour?
Is it long and curved?
Her friend tried the key but could not decide whether an orange was ‘big’. Mia replaces the poor question with one that can be checked.
A key for six animals needs five questions. A key with too few questions leaves two animals together at the end.
Class activity
Key challenge (kitchen or toy box, with an adult): choose four similar things, such as four fruits, four spoons or four toy animals. Build a key that identifies each. Write it as a branching diagram first. Give it to a friend or relative who does not know the items. Did they reach the right names? Which question confused them? Improve it and test again. Write down two changes you made.
Practice
1
Why is ‘Is it small?’ a poor question for a key?
Small is not clear, because people may disagree what counts as small. A question must be checkable.
2
How many questions does a key need to separate five different organisms?
Four (one fewer than the number of organisms).
3
Write a key with three questions for these pets: goldfish, parrot, cat, snake.
One answer: Does it live in water? yes goldfish. No: Does it have legs? no snake. Yes: Does it have feathers? yes parrot, no cat.
4
A friend uses your key and gets the wrong name. What should you do?
Find which question confused them, change it to a clearer question, and test the key again.