GoalUse the seven characteristics as evidence to argue whether viruses and other things are alive.
New words
evidence · facts that support or oppose an ideaclassify · sort into groups using rulesargument · reasons given in support of a decisionhost cell · a living cell that a virus uses to make copies
Explanation
Scientists test an idea against evidence. Here the idea is ‘a virus is alive’, and the seven characteristics are our test. A virus cannot feed, respire, excrete, grow, move or sense its surroundings by itself. It can reproduce, but only inside a host cell, using the cell’s own machinery. Because it fails most tests, many scientists place viruses outside the group of living things. Others say a virus is alive while it is inside a cell, so the question is not simple. A good answer gives reasons, uses the evidence and says which reason is strongest. It is fine to change your mind when new evidence appears.
Characteristic
Cat
Robot vacuum
Virus
nutrition
yes
uses battery power
no
respiration
yes
no
no
growth
yes
no
no
reproduction
yes
no
only inside a host cell
excretion
yes
no
no
sensitivity
yes
some sensors
no
movement
yes
yes
no
Worked examples
Nodira reads the table. The robot vacuum moves and senses, but it never grows or reproduces and it is not made of cells, so she decides it is not alive. A robot is built, not born.
A fire moves, grows, uses oxygen and gives off waste gases. Mia thinks it might be alive. Which characteristic does it fail? Fire cannot reproduce by itself and is not made of cells, so it is not an organism.
For
Against
can reproduce
not made of cells
have coded instructions (RNA)
cannot feed, respire, move or grow alone
Amir writes two reasons for and two against ‘viruses are alive’, then picks the stronger side.
Class activity
Alive-test cards (with a family member): write six names on cards, such as dog, tree, candle, robot toy, mushroom, flame. Give each a score from 0 to 7 using the seven characteristics. Say which cards you think are alive and justify with evidence. Choose the card that was hardest to decide and explain why. Then do the same with a virus card, remembering what you learned about it.
Practice
1
Is a drone that flies, films, avoids walls with its sensors and runs on a battery alive? Use at least three characteristics in your answer.
No. It moves, has sensors and uses energy, but it does not grow, reproduce, excrete or respire, and it is not made of cells.
2
Give two reasons why some scientists say a virus is not a living organism.
It is not made of cells, and it cannot feed, respire, excrete, grow, move or sense things on its own.
3
A seed on a shelf does not appear to do anything. Is it alive? What would you do to find out?
Yes. It is alive but resting. Plant it in damp soil and see whether it grows, which shows the characteristics.
4
Complete the table for a mushroom: which characteristic would you find hard to see?
Characteristic
Seen in a mushroom?
growth
yes
reproduction
yes (spores)
movement
?
Movement is hard to see because it is very slow, but it grows and reproduces, so it is living.