Week 3 · Chapter 1 (C): checking equations with dimensions, powers of ten and prefixes, measurement errors and their sources, direct and indirect measurement · 3 lessons
3
Measurement errors, direct and indirect measurement
Physics Sec 2 Term 1, Unit 1: pp. 16–21
GoalName the sources of measurement error and tell direct from indirect measurement.
New words
measurement error · the difference between a measured value and the true value; no measurement is perfectly exactdirect measurement · one instrument and one reading, such as a volume read in a measuring jugindirect measurement · several measurements combined with a formula, such as density from mass and volume
Explanation
No measurement is perfectly exact. Errors come from four main sources. An unsuitable instrument: a metre stick cannot measure the width of a hair. A defective instrument: a pointer that does not start at zero adds the same error to every reading. A wrong technique: reading a ruler from the side gives a different mark from reading it straight above it. The environment: a draught near a sensitive balance changes its reading. A direct measurement uses one instrument and one reading, like a volume in a measuring jug. An indirect measurement uses a formula and several measurements: volume from length × width × height, or density from mass and volume. In an indirect measurement the small errors of each reading add up, so the result can be less exact than any single reading. Extra: repeating a measurement and averaging reduces the random errors.
Source of error
Example
How to reduce it
unsuitable instrument
metre stick for a hair
choose a finer instrument
defective instrument
pointer not at zero
correct the zero or subtract
wrong technique
reading from the side
look straight at the mark
environment
draught near a balance
shield the instrument
Worked examples
A pencil is measured three times with a ruler: 14.2 cm, 14.3 cm and 14.1 cm. The average is (14.2 + 14.3 + 14.1) ÷ 3 = 42.6 ÷ 3 = 14.2 cm. The readings differ a little because of small slips, and the average reduces their effect.
Indirect: a block is 10 cm × 5 cm × 2 cm and has a mass of 270 g. Volume = 10 × 5 × 2 = 100 cm³. Density = 270 ÷ 100 = 2.7 g/cm³ = 2700 kg/m³. Four readings were needed, and a slip in any of them changes the density.
A kitchen scale shows 20 g with nothing on it. A bag reads 220 g. This is a defective-instrument error: the true mass is 220 − 20 = 200 g.
Class activity
Pencil and parallax, with a grown-up. Measure one pencil three times with a ruler and write the readings in a table, then average them. Next, put a coin on top of the ruler and look at a mark straight from above and then from the side; see how the mark seems to move. Say which source of error this shows and how to avoid it.
Practice
1
Is each direct or indirect: (a) water volume in a jug, (b) area of a table, (c) density of a stone, (d) time with a stopwatch?