Resolution in practice: a lamp hung from two rods, and why the components can be larger than the force
A lantern of weight W hangs from the middle of a rope fixed at two equal heights, and each half makes an angle φ with the horizontal. The weight pulls straight down, and the two ropes must resolve that downward force: each rope pulls with a tension T along itself. Resolve W into two directions, each making 90° − φ with the vertical. By symmetry the two tensions are equal and the sine rule gives T = W sin(90° − φ) / sin(180° − 2φ) = W cos φ / sin 2φ = W / (2 sin φ). For φ = 30° we get T = W. For smaller φ the rope is flatter and the tension is larger, as the table shows. When φ gets close to 0° the tension is huge, and a perfectly horizontal rope (φ = 0°) cannot carry any weight at all, because sin 0° = 0. This is why components can be larger than the force: the two components almost cancel each other sideways while their small downward parts together carry the load.
| Angle φ of each rope with the horizontal | Tension in each rope (W = 30 N) |
|---|---|
| 60° | 17.3 N |
| 30° | 30 N |
| 10° | 86.4 N |
| 5° | 172.1 N |
| 2° | 429.8 N |
Hang a very light bag (under 0.3 kg) from the middle of a string held by two friends at the same height. Ask them to pull the string flatter and flatter. What do they feel? Stop when it is only slightly stretched: never pull a string tight with a heavy bag or an overhead load.