الأسبوع 3 · الفصل الأول «القياس الفيزيائي» (٣): اختبار صحة المعادلات بالأبعاد والقوى العشرية وبوادئ الوحدات وأخطاء القياس ومصادرها والقياس المباشر وغير المباشر · 3 دروس
1
Checking an equation with dimensions
Physics Sec 2 Term 1, Unit 1: pp. 16–21
GoalUse dimensions to test whether an equation can be right, and say what a match does and does not prove.
New words
dimensional homogeneity · both sides of a law have the same dimensions, and so does every term that is added or subtractedsame dimensions · quantities of one kind, such as two lengths, which can be added or comparedcheck · a test that can prove an equation wrong but cannot prove it right
Explanation
You can add or subtract only quantities of one kind: 1 m + 170 cm works after both are in cm (100 + 170 = 270 cm), but 5 kg + 3 s is meaningless. You can multiply or divide any quantities, which creates new ones, like speed from length and time. A law must have the same dimensions on both sides, and this gives a fast test: write the dimensions of each side and compare. If they differ, the equation is certainly wrong. If they match, the equation may be right, but this does not prove it: numbers and factors like ½ or 2π have no dimensions, so the test cannot see them. A dimension check is a filter that catches mistakes, not a proof.
Equation
Left side
Right side
Verdict
v = u + at
LT⁻¹
LT⁻¹ + LT⁻²·T = LT⁻¹
may be right
s = ½at²
L
LT⁻²·T² = L
may be right
s = vt²
L
LT⁻¹·T² = LT
wrong
F = mv
MLT⁻²
M·LT⁻¹ = MLT⁻¹
wrong
Worked examples
Test v = u + at. Here u and v are speeds, LT⁻¹. The term at is LT⁻² × T = LT⁻¹. All three terms are LT⁻¹, so the equation passes and may be right (and it is).
Test s = vt². The left side is a length L. The right side is LT⁻¹ × T² = LT. L is not LT, so the equation fails and is certainly wrong. The check found the error without any numbers.
Test s = at². Left side L; right side LT⁻² × T² = L. It passes, yet the true law is s = ½at² from rest. The ½ has no dimension, so the check could not see the missing factor. A match never proves a law.
Class activity
Equation doctor, with a grown-up. Write the dimensions of v, a, t and s on cards. Make four equations by choosing pieces (for example s = vt, s = at, v = at, v = at²) and test each by writing the dimensions of both sides. Mark each “wrong” or “may be right”. Then invent one equation that passes the test but is still wrong, and explain why.
Practice
1
Can you add 2 m and 30 cm? Give the result in cm.
Yes, after converting: 200 + 30 = 230 cm.
2
Test F = mv by dimensions. Is it right?
F is MLT⁻² but mv is MLT⁻¹. They differ, so it is wrong.
3
Test P = ρgh with [ρ] = ML⁻³, [g] = LT⁻², [h] = L. What dimension does the right side have?
ML⁻³ × LT⁻² × L = ML⁻¹T⁻², which is the dimension of pressure, so it may be right.
4
A pupil says an equation is proved because its dimensions match. Correct the idea.
A match only shows the equation may be right. Numbers such as ½ are invisible to the check.