GoalDescribe three kinds of prototype, explain why designers test them with users, and compare a prototype with a minimum viable product.
New words
prototype · an early model of a product, made to test ideas before the final product is builtfeedback · what testers say they like and dislike about a designminimum viable product (MVP) · an early version of a product with just enough features to sell to keen customersearly adopter · a customer who buys a new product early and is happy to give feedback
Explanation
A prototype is an early model of a product, made to test ideas before the real thing is built. Early prototypes use quick methods and cheap materials, so a change costs little. A visual prototype copies the look, shape and weight, with no working parts at all. A proof-of-principle prototype has only the key functions, to show that the main idea works. A working prototype has almost all of the final functions. Testers try the prototype and give feedback, the team changes the design, and a new prototype may be tested; this repeats until the design is settled. A company may instead sell a minimum viable product (MVP) to keen customers, called early adopters, who give feedback after buying. An MVP earns money early, but a poor one can harm the company’s reputation.
Kind of prototype
What it has
A question it answers
visual
the look, shape and weight; no working parts
Does it feel good in the hand?
proof of principle
only the key functions
Does the main idea work?
working
almost all the final functions
Does it do its job all day?
Worked examples
Prototype
What it is
What the team learns
foam-and-paint model
visual
Is it comfortable to clip on and easy to see?
switch, battery and lamp on a board
proof of principle
Does the switch turn on the lamp?
lamp in a case, nearly finished
working
Does the battery last a week of rides?
Three prototypes of a bike light. A team makes three different models. The foam model cannot light up, the circuit on a board cannot be fixed to a bike, and the nearly finished lamp lacks only the final paint. Each model answers a different question, so the team learns something new from each one.
Round
Feedback from testers
Change made
1
The numbers are too small to read in sunshine.
larger numbers and a brighter screen
2
The two buttons look the same, so I pressed the wrong one.
different shapes and colours
3
I cannot tell by touch which button starts it.
a raised dot on the start button
Rounds of feedback. A team tests a clip-on reminder device with ten users each round. After every round they change one thing and test again. This is the same idea as iterative development in programming: build a little, test, improve.
Prototype
MVP
Who uses it
testers chosen by the team
paying early adopters
Main aim
improve the design
earn money and gather feedback
Main risk
time and money spent on many rounds
customers dislike it and the reputation suffers
Prototype or MVP? A prototype goes to testers chosen by the company before the product is sold. An MVP is sold to real customers who know it is an early version. Both give feedback, but the risks differ: too many prototype rounds waste time and money, while a poor MVP can harm the company’s name.
Class activity
Cardboard prototype (no computer). Invent a small device, such as a pencil-case alarm or a bookmark that lights up. Draw it, then make a visual prototype from paper and card (ask an adult to help with scissors). Write three questions for testers, one about user experience, one about accessibility and one about ergonomics. Ask two people to try the prototype and note their feedback. Change one thing, make the second version and test it again. Write what you learned from each round.
Practice
1
Which kind of prototype is each? Choose visual, proof of principle or working.
Prototype
Kind
(a) A clay stand with the final size and weight, but no electronics.
?
(b) A board with a sensor and a buzzer that shows the alarm idea works, with no case.
?
(c) A device that does nearly everything and lacks only its packaging.
?
(a) visual: it has the size and weight but no electronics; (b) proof of principle: it shows only that the main idea works; (c) working: it does nearly everything and only the packaging is missing.
2
Why do companies use cheap materials and quick methods for their first prototypes?
A change to an early prototype costs little in money and time, so the team can try many ideas and drop the bad ones before paying for the expensive final product.
3
A tester’s comments are shown. Match each to a factor (user experience, accessibility or ergonomics) and suggest one change.
Tester’s comment
Factor
Change
(a) The strap pinched my wrist.
?
?
(b) I could not hear the beep in a noisy room.
?
?
(c) I could not find the settings.
?
?
(a) Ergonomics: use a softer, wider strap. (b) Accessibility: add a vibration or light signal as well as the sound. (c) User experience: put the settings in a clearer place, or add a labelled icon.
4
A company has a good working prototype and is deciding to sell it as an MVP. Give one advantage and one risk.
Advantage: the company earns money early and gets feedback from real customers. Risk: if the early version is poor, customers may be disappointed and the company’s reputation may be damaged.