GoalExplain user experience, accessibility and ergonomics, and use them to judge a device and suggest improvements.
New words
user experience · how a person feels when using a device: is it quick to learn, pleasant and good to look at?accessibility · how easily people with a disability or special need can use a deviceergonomics · designing things to be safe, comfortable and efficient for the human bodyscreen reader · software that reads the text on a screen aloud
Explanation
Designers judge a digital device by three main factors. User experience is how a person feels when using it: is it quick to learn, pleasant and good to look at? Accessibility is how easily people with a disability or special need, for example in sight, hearing, movement or learning, can use it. Ergonomics is the science of making things safe, comfortable and efficient for the human body, such as a keyboard that keeps the wrists straight. A device can be strong on one factor and weak on another. Designers choose features for the group of people they expect to buy the device, so no device suits everybody, but a good designer includes as many people as possible. To judge a device, ask questions about each factor and then suggest improvements.
Factor
Question to ask
A good feature
User experience
Is it pleasant and easy to learn?
clear icons and few steps
Accessibility
Can people with a disability use it?
captions that show speech as text
Ergonomics
Is it comfortable and safe for the body?
a handle shaped to fit the hand
Worked examples
Comment from a tester
Factor
The menu has big pictures and only three choices on each screen.
user experience
A speaker reads each choice aloud, and there is a socket for headphones.
accessibility
The screen is tilted down so that light does not shine back, and the coin slot is at hand height.
ergonomics
A person in a wheelchair can reach the screen because it is mounted low.
accessibility
A ticket machine at a tram stop. A designer lists four comments from testers and sorts them by factor. The comments about reading aloud and reaching the screen are about people who cannot see or reach in the usual way, so they belong to accessibility.
Problem
Factor
Improvement
The headband squeezes after an hour.
ergonomics
softer pads and a lighter frame
The mute button is too small to find by touch.
accessibility
a larger button with a raised dot
The start-up sound is long and cannot be skipped.
user experience
let the user skip the sound
A heavy headset. Testers wore a headset for a long video call. Each problem is matched to a factor, and the designer writes one improvement for it. Notice that one improvement is aimed at one problem, so that the team can test whether it worked.
Feature
Helps people who …
captions on videos
cannot hear the sound well
a screen reader
cannot see the screen well
a large button or a switch
have limited hand movement
a simple menu with few choices
find reading or remembering hard
Features and the people they help. An accessibility feature is aimed at a particular need, so a designer first asks who might struggle. Several features together make a device easier for many people, and some of them help everyone, such as captions in a noisy room.
Class activity
Design audit (no computer). Choose a device at home with an adult’s permission, such as a TV remote, a calculator or a tablet. Make a table with the three factors. Give each factor a score from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent) and write one reason. Ask a family member whose hands or eyes are different from yours to do the same job with it (for example, to change the volume), and note anything they find hard. Write one improvement for the lowest score.
Practice
1
Write user experience, accessibility or ergonomics for each comment.
Comment
Factor
(a) The text can be made larger.
?
(b) I found the camera on the first try, and the screen looks tidy.
?
(c) After half an hour my wrists ache.
?
(d) The device vibrates when a message arrives.
?
(e) The game starts quickly and the colours are pleasant.
?
(a) accessibility; (b) user experience; (c) ergonomics; (d) accessibility; (e) user experience.
2
Name one feature that would help each person use a tablet.
Person
Feature
(a) has difficulty seeing small text
?
(b) cannot hold a device steady
?
(c) cannot hear sounds clearly
?
Possible answers: (a) a screen reader or larger text; (b) a stand, or voice control; (c) captions on videos, or vibration alerts.
3
Why should a designer think about ergonomics when making a keyboard that people use for hours?
A badly shaped keyboard can make the wrists and hands tired or painful when it is used for hours. An ergonomic design keeps the body in a comfortable position, so the user can work longer without pain or injury.
4
A fitness band has a tiny screen and a stiff strap. Suggest one improvement for each of the three factors.
Model answer. User experience: show fewer, clearer numbers on each screen. Accessibility: add vibration and spoken results for people who cannot read the screen. Ergonomics: use a soft, adjustable strap that does not pinch.