GoalDescribe the choices a network designer makes about security, and plan and judge the protection for an invented place.
New words
security breach · a failure of security that lets someone reach devices, data or a network without permissionredundancy · spare equipment or spare copies of data, so work can go on if something failsdata recovery plan · steps for getting data and services back after something is lost or breaksphishing · a fake message that tries to trick you into giving away private details
Explanation
A network must keep data safe from being lost, damaged or seen by people who should not see it. A security breach is when someone gets in without permission. Protection can be physical, such as a locked server room, or digital, such as a firewall, antivirus software, encryption and passwords. A designer also chooses how much backup to keep, with spare equipment and copies of data in another place (some organisations pay a cloud company to keep them offsite), and a plan to get data back. A firewall checks traffic against rules and blocks what breaks them, and antivirus software scans for harmful programs and must be kept up to date. Security must be accessible: a person who cannot see a screen or press small keys also needs a way to log in. Cost matters too, because stronger protection costs more, so the strength should fit how valuable the data is: a software firewall costs less than a hardware one, and a school may need less than a bank. Most breaches start with a human mistake, such as believing a fake message, so staff need training. Data that does no harm if seen, such as opening times, needs less protection than private records.
Choice
The question to ask
Physical and digital measures
What stops people from reaching the devices and the data?
Redundancy and recovery
What happens if hardware fails or data is lost?
Accessibility
Can everyone who is allowed in use the security?
Cost
Is the protection worth what it costs?
Training
Do the users know how to avoid mistakes?
Worked examples
Data kept by the hall
Harm if a stranger sees it
Protection needed
Opening times
none, it is public
little (but keep a backup copy)
Members’ phone numbers and addresses
privacy is lost
strong
Staff login details
a stranger could open all the other data
very strong
Different data, different protection. A community sports hall keeps three kinds of data. The more harm a leak would do, the stronger the protection should be. Opening times are public. Members’ phone numbers and home addresses are private. The staff’s login details could open everything.
Measure
Type
Cost
What it protects against
Locked cupboard for the server
physical
low
people reaching the machine
Staff training session
people
medium
mistakes, such as believing fake messages
Backup copy kept in another building
digital / physical
medium
loss from fire, theft or a broken disk
Door lock that reads a fingerprint
physical (uses biometrics)
high
people entering the server room
Choosing within a limited budget. The hall can only pay for some measures. Each measure protects against something different, so the hall compares what each one does for the money. The hall decides to start with the cheap ones and with the measure that protects the most important data.
Step that is hard
Who may find it hard
A way to help
Typing a code on small keys
people with limited hand movement
a door card or a larger keypad
Reading a code on a small screen
people with poor eyesight
a speaker that reads the steps aloud
Remembering a long password
people who find remembering hard
a login card or a second device that confirms the login
Security everyone can use. The hall’s door panel needs a four-digit code typed on small keys, and the staff computer needs a typed password. A member with poor eyesight or limited hand movement may struggle with both. The hall adds ways in that keep the same strength.
Class activity
Plan the guards (no computer). Invent a small place, such as a repair café, a choir or a bike-share stand. List three kinds of data it keeps and decide how strong the protection of each must be. Choose four measures from different rows of the table in the explanation, and write one reason for each (including its cost). Add one change that makes the security easier to use for people with a disability. Swap plans with a partner and judge them: Is the strongest protection on the most important data? Can everyone use it? Is any money wasted?
Practice
1
A pet shelter keeps these three kinds of data. Rank them from needing the least protection to needing the most, and give a reason for the top one.
Data kept by the shelter
Rank (1 = least protection, 3 = most)
The shelter’s opening times
?
A volunteer rota with names and phone numbers
?
The shelter’s bank login details
?
Least: the opening times. Middle: the volunteer rota with names and phone numbers. Most: the bank login details. A stranger who has them could take money, so they need the strongest protection.
2
Say whether each measure is physical or digital: a locked door to the office, a firewall, a key card for a door, antivirus software, encryption of files.
Measure
Physical or digital?
a locked door to the office
?
a firewall
?
a key card for a door
?
antivirus software
?
encryption of files
?
A locked door: physical. A firewall: digital. A key card for a door: physical. Antivirus software: digital. Encryption of files: digital.
3
The shelter’s login uses a code on a touch screen with small buttons. Give one person who may find it hard, and suggest a change that keeps the security strong.
Step in the login
Detail
1
type a four-digit code
2
on a touch screen
3
with small buttons
A person with limited hand movement (or poor eyesight) may find small buttons hard. A key card, a larger keypad or a spoken prompt would help without making the security weaker.
4
A message says: ‘Your account will be closed in one hour! Click the link and type your password.’ Give two signs that it may be fake, and say what you should do.
Signs: it creates panic with a very short time, and it asks you to type your password after clicking a link. Do not click or reply; show it to a trusted adult, and check with the real organisation another way.