GoalEvaluate how a micro:bit project was built, with positive and negative points about the product, the way of working and the teamwork.
New words
evaluation · a review that gives both the good points and the weak points of somethingdevelopment log · a short record of each version: what was added, how the test went and what changed
Explanation
When a project ends, evaluate it. An evaluation says what went well and what went wrong, and gives a reason for each. Your points can be about three things: the final product, the way you made it, and how you worked with other people. A development log makes this easy, because it lists every version, test and change. Positive points are not boasting, and negative points are not blame: both help the next project. A good evaluation is specific. ‘It was fine’ says nothing, but ‘the test at 10 jumps failed because I used > 10, and I fixed it’ tells the reader something useful.
Area to cover
Example question
The final product
does it meet every requirement?
The way it was made
which tests found faults, and how were they fixed?
Working with others
were the jobs shared fairly, and did we listen to each other?
Worked examples
Version
Added
Test result
What changed
1
count and show jumps
passed
nothing
2
button B starts again
passed
nothing
3
happy face at 10 or more
failed at 10 jumps
> 10 changed to > 9
4
radio to the coach
coach’s lights stayed blank
not finished
A development log for the jump counter. Each row is one pass round the loop. The log shows that only one pass, version 3, ended in a change to the code. It also shows the one thing that was never finished: the radio version.
Statement
Positive or negative?
Area
The counter shows the right number after every shake.
positive
product
Our test at 10 jumps failed because we used > 10.
negative
way it was made
Building one part at a time made faults easy to find.
positive
way it was made
We ran out of time, so the radio part does not work.
negative
product
Mia built the code and Leo wrote the tests, and we checked each other’s work.
positive
working with others
Sorting evaluation points. Every sentence is a point about the project. The table says whether it is positive or negative and which area it belongs to. The sentence about the radio is negative, because the product does not meet its fourth requirement.
Version 4, the radio part. The skipper’s micro:bit sends the number in group 4, but the coach’s micro:bit listens in group 5. Only micro:bits in the same group hear each other. The user shakes three times and the coach’s lights stay blank. Changing the coach’s group to 4 would make them show 1, 2 and 3.
Class activity
Write an evaluation (no computer). Think of a group job you did, such as making a poster or planning a picnic, or use an invented micro:bit project. Draw three columns: product, way it was made, working with others. In each column write one positive point and one negative point, each with a reason. Read them to a partner. Did every point say what happened, or are some too vague, like ‘it was good’?
Practice
1
Say whether each statement is positive or negative, and whether it is about the product, the way it was made, or working with others. (a) Our program never stopped working in testing. (b) We did not write the requirements, so we kept changing our minds. (c) Ravi did all the work while Omar waited. (d) The finished program did only 2 of the 4 requirements. (e) Testing after each change helped us find mistakes early.
(a) positive, product. (b) negative, the way it was made. (c) negative, working with others. (d) negative, product. (e) positive, the way it was made.
2
The sender’s micro:bit and the receiver’s micro:bit are both in group 6. The user presses A, then B, then A. What does the receiver show after each press?
After the first press it shows 2, after the second press it shows the yes icon, and after the third press it shows 2. The number 2 is not more than 5, so it is shown. The number 8 is more than 5, so the yes icon shows.
3
The user presses A once. What do the lights show, in order, and how long do the three pauses take altogether?
The lights show 3, then 2, then 1, and then the yes icon. The variable time starts at 3, and each change by -1 lowers it by 1 before the next show number. The three pauses of 1000 ms add up to 3 seconds. The yes icon appears after the last pause and stays on.
4
Use the log to write an evaluation of this door-sign project. Give at least one positive and one negative point, and name the area of each.
Version
Added
Test result
What changed
1
A shows the yes icon
passed
nothing
2
B shows the no icon
A after B still showed no
wrong block in A, replaced
3
shake shows a sad face
not started
ran out of time
Model answer: Positive (product): the yes icon and the no icon both work, so two of the three requirements are met. Positive (way it was made): testing version 2 found that A after B still showed no, and the fault was corrected at once. Negative (product): the sad face for a closed door was not finished, because there was no time. Negative (way it was made): the time was not planned, so the last part was left out.