Week 3 · Units 2–3: Hierarchy of quadrilaterals; data collection and sampling methods · 4 lessons
4
Fair samples, questionnaires and interviews
Student’s Book 8: Units 2–3, pp. 15–24
GoalChoose a sample in the same ratio as the population and spot problems in questions.
New words
bias · an unfair influence that pushes answers in one directionquestionnaire · a set of written questions given to many peopleinterview · a conversation in which one person asks another the questions
Explanation
Some groups in a population are bigger than others. A swimming club has 36 juniors and 24 seniors. A fair sample of 10 should keep the same ratio. 36 : 24 simplifies to 3 : 2, so take 6 juniors and 4 seniors. A questionnaire is quick and cheap, but its questions must be fair. A biased question pushes you towards one answer. A question must also be clear, and the answer choices must not overlap. Trial your questionnaire on a few people first. In an interview you can explain a question, but it takes longer.
Group
Members
In the sample of 10
Juniors
36
6
Seniors
24
4
Total
60
10
Worked examples
Group
Members
In the sample of 12
Girls
30
8
Boys
15
4
A choir has 30 girls and 15 boys. Choose a sample of 12 in the same ratio. 30 : 15 simplifies to 2 : 1, which is 3 parts. Each part is 12 ÷ 3 = 4. So take 8 girls and 4 boys.
Spot the bias: ‘Don’t you agree that homework should be banned?’ This leads people to say yes. A fair version is: ‘How do you feel about the amount of homework? Too much, about right or too little.’
A question has these answer boxes: ‘0–5 hours’, ‘5–10 hours’, ‘over 10 hours’. The number 5 fits in two boxes. A fix: ‘0–4 hours’, ‘5–9 hours’ and ‘10 hours or more’.
Class activity
Mini survey: write three questions asking people how they travel to school. Try them out on three people at home or in class. Which question was unclear? Rewrite it. Say whether you would use an interview or a questionnaire for 100 people, and why.
Practice
1
A club has 30 adults and 20 children. A sample of 10 is chosen in the same ratio. How many adults and how many children?
30 : 20 = 3 : 2. Each of the 5 parts is 2 people, so 6 adults and 4 children.
2
Rewrite this question so that it is fair: ‘Our amazing canteen is the best place to eat, isn’t it?’
For example: ‘How would you rate the canteen? Poor, OK or good.’
3
Explain why ‘How old are you? Young or old’ is a poor question.
People decide differently what young and old mean. Age ranges such as 12–13, 14–15 would be clear.
4
Give one advantage and one disadvantage of an interview compared with a questionnaire.
Advantage: the interviewer can explain a question. Disadvantage: it takes longer and fewer people can be asked.