Week 14 · Unit 12: Comparing and interpreting data · 4 lessons
3
Which average is best?
Student’s Book 8: Unit 12, pp. 105–114
GoalExplain the strengths and weaknesses of the mean, median, mode and range and choose a sensible average.
New words
extreme value · a value much bigger or smaller than the restmisleading · giving a wrong idea, even if the numbers are correctmean · the total divided by the number of values
Explanation
Each average has strengths and weaknesses. The mean uses every value, but one extreme value can pull it up or down, and it may not be a possible value. The median is not affected by extreme values, but it ignores how big the values at the ends are. The mode is easy to find and is always a value in the data, but there may be no mode or several. The range is easy to find and good for comparing spread, but one extreme value can change it a lot. A statement can be true and still misleading. When a set has an extreme value, the median or the mode usually describes a typical value better than the mean.
Measure
Strength
Weakness
Mean
uses all the data
pulled by extreme values
Median
not affected by extreme values
does not use all the data
Mode
always a value in the data; easy
may be none, or several
Range
easy; compares spread
changed a lot by one extreme value
Worked examples
Ana counts the messages she gets on six days: 3, 4, 4, 4, 5, 40 (one day was a very busy group chat). The mean is 60 ÷ 6 = 10. The median is 4 and the mode is 4. Ana says: ‘I get 10 messages a day on average.’ This is true for the mean, but misleading, because on five of the six days she gets 5 or fewer. The median or mode, 4, is a better description of a typical day.
A shoe shop recorded these sizes sold in one day: 3, 4, 4, 5, 5, 5, 6, 6, 7, 8. The mean is 5.3, which is not a real shoe size. The mode is 5. The shop wants to know which size to order most of, so the mode is the best choice.
A teacher says: ‘The mean mark is 62.’ Another says: ‘The median mark is 70.’ If most students scored between 65 and 75 and a few scored very low marks, the low marks have pulled the mean down. The median is then closer to a typical mark.
Class activity
Misleading headlines: ask three people at home for their pocket money or the number of hours they sleep. Add a made-up extreme value (for example 15 sleeping hours or $200). Find the mean and the median before and after. Which one changed more?
Practice
1
Find the mean, median and mode of 4, 5, 5, 6, 40. Which average gives the best idea of a typical value?
Mean 12, median 5, mode 5. The median or mode is better, because 40 is an extreme value that pulls the mean up.
2
Which average (mean, median or mode) is best for each job? (a) A shop wants the most popular T-shirt colour. (b) A teacher wants the middle mark of a class. (c) A coach wants the total of a player’s points shared equally over 5 games.
(a) mode (b) median (c) mean
3
Minutes that 8 patients waited at a clinic: 4, 5, 5, 5, 6, 7, 8, 40. The clinic says ‘the average wait is 10 minutes’. A patients’ group says ‘people usually wait about 5 minutes’. Can both be right?
Yes. The mean is 80 ÷ 8 = 10 and the median is 5.5 (mode 5). The 40-minute wait pulls the mean up. The median or mode shows what usually happens.
4
Why can the range be a poor measure of spread when one value is far from the others?
The range only uses the biggest and the smallest value. One extreme value can make the range big even if all the other values are close together.