GoalExplain how simulations differ from simple models and weigh their advantages and disadvantages.
New words
simulation · a computer model that uses a lot of data and moving pictures, so that you can watch what could happensimulator · software or equipment that imitates a real situation so that people can practiseprediction · a statement about what will probably happen next, based on datagraphics · pictures and animation made by a computer
Explanation
A simulation uses a lot of data and often moving pictures, so that you can watch what could happen. It is bigger and more detailed than a simple model. A simulator lets people practise or test without danger or cost, for example a driving simulator for learner drivers. Scientists use models to test their ideas and make predictions. Weather forecasters use models that take in data from all over the world. Shops and bakeries use sales data to predict how much stock to prepare before a festival. Hospitals use models of patient numbers to plan how many beds they need. A simulation lets people make mistakes without anyone being hurt, and it can repeat a test again and again. But it takes time and money to build, and real life has more factors than any model holds, so predictions can be wrong.
real situation→data and rules→model or simulation→predictions
Worked examples
rainfall and river data→flood simulation→predicted river level→warning
A flood simulation. Data about rainfall, the river level and the ground go in. The rules say how water flows. A prediction of the river level comes out, and a warning can be sent before the water rises.
Advantages
Disadvantages
people can make mistakes and nobody is hurt
building one costs a lot of time and money
no real equipment is used up or broken
real life has more factors than the model holds, so it can be wrong
the same test can be repeated with one factor changed
old or poor data gives poor predictions
Advantages and disadvantages of using a simulation.
Using past data to predict. A bakery sold these numbers of sweet buns. Week 4 was a festival week and sales doubled. The model predicts that the next festival week will need about 90 buns, so the baker prepares extra.
Class activity
Door simulation (no computer): draw a plan of a classroom on paper with one door. Use 20 coins as pupils. In each turn, one coin may leave through each door. Count how many turns the whole class needs to leave. Now draw a second door and play again. What do you predict for three doors, before you try? Write the prediction first and then test it. Change one factor each time and write down the results. A real simulation does this with a computer, much faster and with many more factors.
Practice
1
Decide whether each is a data model or a simulation, and say why.
Situation
Model or simulation?
(a) a spreadsheet predicts how many lunches a canteen should cook
?
(b) a moving-picture program lets a trainee driver react to ice on a road
?
(c) a database lists all the books in a school library
?
(a) Data model: it uses a spreadsheet and formulae to predict food orders. (b) Simulation: it uses graphics and lets the learner react to events. (c) Data model: a database holds records but does not imitate anything moving.
2
Give one advantage and one disadvantage of testing the fire exits of a new building design with a simulation.
Advantage: it is safe and cheap, because nobody has to be in a real fire and the building does not have to be built first. Disadvantage: it cannot include every factor, such as how real people behave when they are scared, so it may not be exactly right.
3
A shop sold ice creams each month. Use the chart to predict which month needs the most stock next year. What could make the prediction wrong?
July sold the most, so the model predicts that July needs the most stock. The prediction could be wrong if next summer is much cooler or rainier, because the weather is a factor the sales figures do not show.
4
List four factors in a model of the queue at a school gate in the morning.
For example: the number of pupils, the number of gates, how long each pupil takes to get through, the time the gate opens, the time pupils arrive. (Any four sensible factors.)