Week 26 · Unit 7.6: Sequencing and pattern recognition · 3 lessons
1
A first rough version
Computing 7: Unit 7.6, pp. 182–224
GoalExplain what a prototype is and why makers build one before the final product.
New words
prototype · a first working model of a product, built to test an idea before the final version is madeproject plan · a written plan that says what a product must do, what its parts are, how it will be tested and how the results will be useduser feedback · what the people who try a product say about it: what works, what confuses them and what they want changedbug · a mistake in a program that stops it working correctly
Explanation
Before a company makes the final product, it builds a prototype. A prototype is a first working model, built to test an idea. A hardware product, such as a bicycle, needs a physical prototype. This can be a cardboard model that shows the size, the materials and the cost. A software product needs a working model of the program. Real users try the prototype and give feedback. Testing also finds bugs, and it is cheaper to fix a bug early than after the release. People stop using software that is full of bugs. Everything is planned first in a project plan.
Four planks, found by measuring the cut-out pieces
Is it steady?
It wobbles, so a cross bar is needed
A physical prototype answers questions about size, materials and cost. Nodira’s club wants to make a bench for the school garden, so it first builds a cardboard model.
User feedback
Kind
Planned change
The times are too small to read
look and feel
bigger numbers
Pressing Back closes the whole program
bug
fix the Back button
I want to save my usual stop
new idea
add a Save button
A software prototype is a working model of the program. Leo makes a first version of a bus-timetable program and lets five people try it. He writes their feedback in a table and decides what to do about each comment.
Part of the plan
Ana’s answer
What it must do
multiply every amount in a recipe by the number of people
Sections
ask for the number of people, calculate, show the new amounts
Inputs and outputs
input: number of people; output: the new list of amounts
How to test
try 1, 2 and 10 people and check by hand
How to use the results
fix bugs, then ask three cooks what to change
The project plan is written before the prototype. This is Ana’s plan for a program that scales a recipe for more people.
Class activity
Paper prototype (no computer). Plan a program for a school library with three screens: a home screen, a search screen and a results screen. Draw each screen on its own sheet of paper, with buttons. A friend is the user: they point at a button with a pencil, and you swap in the right sheet and say what happens. On small slips of paper write one thing that worked, one thing that was confusing and one idea. Then draw a second version of the screen that caused the most trouble.
Practice
1
Explain in your own words why a designer builds a prototype before the final product.
A prototype is a first working model. Users can try it and give feedback, and the designers can find bugs and bad ideas early, when they are cheap to fix. Then the final product is better and does not disappoint people.
2
Is each of these a physical prototype or a software prototype? Copy the table and fill in the last column.
Description
Physical or software?
1
A wooden model of a new playground slide
?
2
A first version of a quiz program with only three questions
?
3
A cardboard box shaped like a new phone case
?
4
A working timer program that users test for a week
?
1 physical (a model you can touch). 2 software (a working first version of a program). 3 physical. 4 software.
3
A friend says: “Let’s skip the prototype and release the program straight away. The users can find the bugs.” Give two reasons why this is a bad plan.
Possible reasons: users who meet bugs get a bad impression and may stop using the program; it is cheaper to fix bugs before the release; a prototype shows what users want, so the designers can improve the look and feel before the final product.
4
Put these steps in the right order. Write the letters in order, for example B, E, …
Letter
Step
A
Users try the prototype and give feedback
B
Write the project plan
C
Improve the prototype
D
Release the final product
E
Build the prototype
B, E, A, C, D. First the project plan (B), then the prototype is built (E), users try it and give feedback (A), the prototype is improved (C), and last the final product is released (D).