Unit 6: two kinds of skills, personal qualities and relative clauses
Week 13 · Unit 6 Soft Skills vs. Hard Skills (A): an article about two kinds of skills (reference only), contrast and word meaning, a listening on personal qualities (our own read-aloud text), creative / reliable / resilient, defining and non-defining relative clauses · 3 lessons
3
Relative clauses: defining and non-defining
English Secondary 2 Term 1, Unit 6 Lesson 3: pp. 77–78
GoalUse defining and non-defining relative clauses with who, which, that, whose and where, and avoid common slips.
New words
relative clause · a part of a sentence that gives more information about a noundefining · giving the information that we need to know which onenon-defining · giving extra information; we put commas around itpronoun · a word such as who or which that stands for a nounobject · the person or thing that receives the actionwhose · used to show that something belongs to someone
Explanation
A defining relative clause tells us which person or thing we mean, so there are no commas. Use who for people, which for things, that for people or things, whose for possession and where for places: The girl who won the prize is my cousin. The book that I borrowed was long. The student whose project won is my friend. This is the library where I read. When who, which or that is the object of the clause, we can leave it out: The book (that) I borrowed was long. We cannot leave it out when it is the subject. A non-defining relative clause adds extra information. It has a comma on both sides and we never use that: My brother, who works in a bakery, is learning to cook. The workshop, which opens at six, is near the bridge. The pronoun cannot be left out. Slips: the man he lives (wrong), the book what (wrong), whose her project (wrong), where it has (wrong), the teacher which (wrong).
Type
Pronouns
Commas
Example
Defining
who, which, that, whose, where
no
The girl who won the prize is my cousin.
Non-defining
who, which, whose, where (not that)
yes, both sides
My brother, who works in a bakery, is learning to cook.
Leave out
only the object
–
The book (that) I borrowed was long.
Slips
he, what, her after the pronoun
–
the man who lives (not the man he lives)
Worked examples
Defining. “The girl ___ won the prize is my cousin.” A person, subject: who (or that). The clause tells us which girl, so there are no commas.
Leave out. “The book that I borrowed was long.” I is the subject of borrowed, so that is the object and can be left out: The book I borrowed was long. “The girl who won the prize” cannot lose who.
Non-defining. “My brother, who works in a bakery, is learning to cook.” The commas show extra information. We cannot say that here, and we cannot leave who out.
Slips. “The student whose her project won” → The student whose project won. “The man he lives next door” → The man who lives next door.
Class activity
Describe a place. Write four sentences about a place at school or at home. Use one defining clause with where, one with who, one non-defining clause with which and one with whose. Put commas in the non-defining sentence.
Practice
1
Complete: The girl ___ won the prize is my cousin. (who / which / whose)
who.
2
Complete: The student ___ project won the prize is my friend. (who / whose / where)
whose.
3
Complete: This is the library ___ I read every afternoon. (where / who / whose)
where.
4
Complete with commas: My brother ___ works in a bakery ___ is learning to cook. (who)
My brother, who works in a bakery, is learning to cook.
5
Correct the slip: “The teacher which taught us last year has moved.”
The teacher who taught us last year has moved. We use who for people.