Reading about fake news: spotting reliable sources
Unit 5 is about how media can change what we think; its title is on page 60 and its aims are on page 61. To read an article, find the main idea of each paragraph: what is it about in a few words? Then ask how the paragraphs connect: problem, example, advice. To tell whether a source is reliable, ask five questions. Who is the author? When was it written? Is there evidence, such as a quote, a number or a named person? Is the tone calm or sensational, with many capital letters and exclamation marks? Do other reliable sources say the same? A claim without a source, a date and evidence should make you careful. Before you share a message, check it; if you are not sure, ask an adult. Never share a password. The book’s article on page 62 is about false news and is named by page only. Read it after this lesson and rate its sources with the five questions.
| Question | Reliable sign | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Author | a named person or group | nobody knows |
| Date | a clear date | no date or very old |
| Evidence | a quote, number or notice | only “everyone says” |
| Tone | calm | capital letters, many !! |
On Monday morning a message spread through the class chat: “School trip cancelled!! Everyone is saying so.” By break, half the class was upset. Nada, the class representative, decided to check. She asked three questions. Who wrote it? Nobody knew, because the message had been forwarded many times. When was it written? There was no date. What is the tone? The two exclamation marks and the words “Everyone is saying so” made it sensational, but they gave no evidence. Nada asked the trip teacher, who showed her the notice board: the trip had been moved from Thursday to Friday because of exams. Nada posted a calm correction with a photo of the notice. She also asked her friends to wait for a reliable source before they forward a claim. “A headline can make you angry,” she said, “but a source makes you sure.”
Source check. Find a short news item or a message you have received. Answer the five questions (author, date, evidence, tone, other sources) and decide: reliable, not sure or unreliable. Explain your decision to a grown-up. Do not name real websites or real people.