Reading a story: inference from words and actions
A writer can tell us a feeling directly: She was nervous. A better writer often shows it. When we infer, we use what a character says and does and compare the two. If the words say one thing and the actions say another, the actions are usually the truer clue. For example, a boy says, “I am not worried,” but he bites his pencil and looks at the clock. We infer that he is worried. To explain an inference, use this frame: The writer does not say that she is …, but … (action), so she is probably … . Look for body language, speed, voice, what the character does when nobody watches, and what other people say. In your reader, Around the World in Eighty Days, read Chapter 2 on pages 6 to 10. The book’s questions on this chapter are on pages 44 to 48. After you read, practise inference with words and actions.
| Clue | Question to ask |
|---|---|
| Words | What does the character say? Is it true? |
| Actions | What does the character do? How fast, how carefully? |
| Contrast | Do the words and the actions agree? |
| Others | What do other people say or do? |
Reem had told everyone that she was not nervous about the school play. “It is only a few lines,” she said, and laughed. On the day of the last rehearsal she arrived first and sat alone in the empty hall with the script on her knees. Her lips moved, but no sound came out. When the stage manager called her name, she dropped the script and picked it up so quickly that three pages fell out. “I know my part,” she said, but she held the pages so tightly that the corners bent. During her scene she looked at the floor, and her voice was so soft that the teacher said, “Louder, please.” Afterwards Reem walked to the corridor and read the same page five times. When her friend Kareem asked how it went, she said, “Fine,” and turned the page over so that he could not see the notes in the margin.
Words against actions. Think of a person who says one thing but does another (for example, someone who says “I am not tired” and yawns). Write the words, two actions and your inference with the frame: The person does not say that …, but … so …. Do not retell a story.