Reading about education: inference and evaluation
At B1+ level, reading questions go beyond facts. A main idea question asks what the whole text is about. An inference question asks what the clues suggest. An evaluation question, for example How effective is the change? Why?, asks you to judge. To evaluate, collect evidence from the text, for and against, then give a reasoned answer: The change seems effective, because attendance rose, but it is too early to be sure, because the test results did not improve. Notice small signals: the word however shows a contrast, and phrases such as it is too early to know show that the writer is careful. To work out the meaning of a word, look at the sentence and at words with similar meaning: memorisation is explained by learning by repeating. The book’s passage on pages 37 and 38 is about a national education plan. Read it after this lesson and write one question of each kind: main idea, inference and evaluation.
| Question | What you need |
|---|---|
| Main idea | The sentence that covers the whole text. |
| Inference | A clue and the idea that it shows. |
| Evaluation | Evidence for and against, then a judgement. |
| Word meaning | The sentence around the word and similar words. |
Reed Lane School changed its timetable this year. In the old timetable, students sat in lessons from eight until two, and many spent their evenings on memorisation for tests. The new curriculum keeps the main subjects but gives every Wednesday afternoon to projects. In a project, groups of four choose a question, such as how to make the yard safer, and look for answers with books, interviews and simple measurements. Teachers say that critical thinking has improved, because students now ask why before they accept an answer. However, some parents worry that marks may fall, and the school admits that it is too early to know. Last term the test results stayed the same, but attendance on Wednesdays rose from 88 to 96 out of every 100 students. The head teacher says that creativity cannot be measured with a test, but she will keep watching the results.
My judgement. Think of one change in your school (a new rule, a new club or a new timetable). Write two pieces of evidence for it and one against it. Then write a judgement with because. Read it to a grown-up.