Listening to a debate: opinions and persuasive phrases
In a debate two speakers give different opinions. When you listen, note for each speaker: the opinion, two reasons and any example. Use two columns. Then decide which speaker you agree with, and why. Debaters use signal phrases. To give an opinion: I believe that …, In my view … . To agree: I tend to agree because … . To disagree politely: I see your point, but I am not entirely convinced that … . To give a reason: First, …, Second, … . To suggest another idea: I would prefer … . Never attack the person; speak about the idea. Our text is a debate about phones in class, read aloud by a grown-up. The book’s radio debate on pages 64 and 65 has its own speakers; ours are invented, and the statements are ours. In the role-play, give your own opinion with a reason.
| Function | Phrase |
|---|---|
| Give an opinion | I believe that … / In my view … |
| Agree | I tend to agree because … |
| Disagree politely | I see your point, but I am not entirely convinced that … |
| Suggest | I would prefer a rule that … |
Speaker one, Mr Hany: I believe that our school should have a rule that phones stay in bags during lessons. First, many students check messages instead of listening. Second, in a test last term, ten phones rang. A clear regulation would be fair to everybody. Speaker two, Ms Dina: I see your point, but I am not entirely convinced. Phones are also useful tools: students look up words and take photos of the board. A total ban would be a restriction that removes these benefits. I would prefer a rule that phones are used only when the teacher agrees. Speaker one: That might work, but who will check? Speaker two: The class itself. If every student is responsible, nobody needs to check.
Two sides. Choose a school question (for example: Should the school day start later?). Write one opinion for each side with a reason and a polite phrase. Then say which side you prefer and why. Read it to a grown-up.