Hydrogen’s lines, Bohr’s limits and the modern theory
الأسبوع 6 · الباب الثاني (٢): خطوط طيف الهيدروجين المرئية ونجاح نموذج بور وقصوره والنظرية الذرية الحديثة (الطبيعة المزدوجة للإلكترون ومبدأ عدم التأكد والسحابة الإلكترونية والأوربيتال) · 3 دروس
2
What Bohr’s model explained and where it failed
Chemistry Sec 2 Term 1, Chapter 2: pp. 27–30
GoalState what Bohr’s model explained and its four shortcomings.
New words
success · a result the model explained correctly: hydrogen’s line spectrumshortcoming · a place where the model fails to match what is observedthree-dimensional · having length, width and height; real atoms are, but Bohr’s circles are flat
Explanation
Bohr’s model was a big step. It explained the line spectrum of hydrogen, and it brought in the idea of the quantum: energy changes in definite amounts. But it has limits. First, it works for hydrogen but not for helium, which has two electrons, or for any bigger atom. Second, it treats the electron only as a particle. Third, it assumes that the position and the speed of the electron can both be known exactly at the same moment. Fourth, it pictures a flat circular atom, while real atoms are three-dimensional. Scientists did not throw the model away: it was improved by the modern theory, and it is still a good first picture of hydrogen.
Bohr’s model
Verdict
explains hydrogen’s line spectrum
success
introduces the quantum idea
success
fails for helium and bigger atoms
shortcoming
electron only a particle
shortcoming
position and speed both exact
shortcoming
flat circular atom
shortcoming
Worked examples
Sort the statements. “It explains the lines of hydrogen”: success. “It predicts the lines of helium correctly”: not true, a shortcoming. “It uses the idea of the quantum”: success. “Atoms are flat discs”: not true, a shortcoming.
Why does helium break the model? Helium has two electrons, which also act on each other. Bohr’s model was built for one electron around a nucleus, so it cannot give the right lines for atoms with more electrons.
Is a model that fails useless? No. A map of a city can leave out the trees and still be useful. Bohr’s model explains hydrogen and began the quantum idea; later models keep what worked and fix what did not.
Class activity
Two-column card. Fold a sheet of paper in half. On the left write what Bohr’s model did well, on the right its limits, using your own words. Add one sentence saying why it is still taught. Check the card against the table and fix any missing point. No materials other than paper and a pen.
Practice
1
Give two successes of Bohr’s model.
It explained the line spectrum of hydrogen and introduced the idea of the quantum.
2
Give two shortcomings of Bohr’s model.
Any two: it works only for hydrogen; it treats the electron only as a particle; it assumes position and speed can both be known exactly; it gives a flat circular atom.
3
A pupil says: “Bohr’s model is wrong, so it is useless.” Reply in two sentences.
It is not useless: it explained the lines of hydrogen and introduced the quantum idea. It has limits, and the modern theory improves on it.