الأسبوع 5 · الباب الثاني «بنية الذرة» (١): نموذجا طومسون ورذرفورد وتجربة رقيقة الذهب وطيف الانبعاث الخطي وفروض بور · 3 دروس
1
From Thomson’s model to Rutherford’s nucleus
Chemistry Sec 2 Term 1, Chapter 2: pp. 24–27
GoalDescribe Thomson’s model, what the gold-foil experiment showed (three observations, three conclusions) and Rutherford’s model of the atom.
New words
alpha particle · a positively charged particle (a helium nucleus) used by Rutherford’s team as a tiny probenucleus · the very small, dense, positively charged centre of the atom that holds most of its massgold-foil experiment · Geiger and Marsden’s experiment, directed by Rutherford: alpha particles aimed at very thin gold foil
Explanation
Thomson pictured the atom as a ball of positive charge with electrons embedded in it, neutral overall. Rutherford’s team tested this idea by aiming positive alpha particles at very thin gold foil, with a screen that flashed where a particle landed. Words only: this experiment needs a radioactive source and is done only in specialist laboratories. Three results followed. Most particles passed straight through, so the atom is mostly empty space. A very few bounced back, so there is a tiny, dense centre, the nucleus, with most of the mass. Some were deflected sideways, so the nucleus is positive and pushes the positive alpha particles away. Rutherford’s model of 1911 therefore has a small positive nucleus, electrons around it, and equal total positive and negative charge. It did not explain why the electrons stay out and do not fall into the nucleus.
Observation
Conclusion
most alpha particles pass straight through
most of the atom is empty space
a very few bounce back
a tiny, dense nucleus holds most of the mass
some are deflected to the side
the nucleus is positive and repels the positive particles
Worked examples
An invented run of 20 000 alpha particles. Suppose 19 897 pass almost straight, 3 bounce back, and about a hundred bend a little. The huge majority passing through says the atom is mostly empty space; the tiny number bouncing back says whatever stopped them is very small but heavy. The numbers are invented, only to show the pattern: nearly all straight, very few back.
Thomson
Rutherford
positive charge
spread through the atom
in a tiny nucleus
empty space
none
mostly empty
explains bounce-back
no
yes
Two models compared. In Thomson’s model the positive charge is spread through the whole ball and electrons are scattered inside it, so nothing should stop a heavy particle. In Rutherford’s model the positive charge and the mass are packed into a tiny nucleus with electrons far around it. Only Rutherford’s model fits the bounced and bent particles.
Why does a positive nucleus deflect positive particles? Like charges repel. A positive alpha particle passing close to the positive nucleus is pushed sideways, and one heading straight at it is pushed back. A particle far from the nucleus feels almost nothing and goes straight on, which is why most go straight.
Class activity
Marbles and a hidden shape, with a grown-up. Place a shallow cardboard box on the floor and hide a small obstacle under a sheet of paper laid in it, for example a coin or a small cup. A helper arranges it without showing you. Roll about 20 marbles across from the same spot, one at a time, and mark where each leaves the box. Work out the size and position of the hidden object from the marks. Say how this is like Rutherford’s method and why you need many marbles.
Practice
1
Which observation shows that most of an atom is empty space?
Most alpha particles pass straight through the foil.
2
What does the deflection of some alpha particles tell us about the charge of the nucleus?
The nucleus is positive, because it repels the positive alpha particles.
3
A pupil says: “Most alpha particles bounced back.” Correct the statement.
Very few bounced back. Most went straight through and some were deflected.
4
Give two features of Rutherford’s model.
A small, dense, positive nucleus holds most of the mass; the electrons, with very little mass, are around it; and the total negative charge equals the positive charge, so the atom is neutral.