Week 35 · Unit 19: Interpreting and discussing results · 4 lessons
3
Comparing with averages and range
Coursebook 9: Unit 19, pp. 184–189
GoalCompare two sets of data using the mean, median, mode and range, choose the most suitable average, and explain which set is better for a purpose.
New words
average · a typical value: the mean, the median or the modeconsistent · with values close together, so a small rangeextreme value · a value much bigger or smaller than the rest
Explanation
To compare two sets of data, find an average for each and a range for each. The averages tell you which set is higher or lower on average. The ranges tell you which set is more spread out; the smaller the range, the more consistent the data. The mean uses every value but one extreme value can pull it far from the others. The median is not affected by extreme values, so it is often the better average when there are some. The mode, the value that occurs most often, is useful for things like shoe sizes. Put your results in a table, then write sentences that use the numbers. Finally decide what the question needs: a high average, or reliable results, or both.
Measure
Tells you
Pulled by extreme values?
Mean
the typical value, using every value
yes
Median
the middle value
no
Mode
the most common value
no
Range
how spread out the values are
yes
Worked examples
Machine
Mean
Median
Range
A
500 ml
500 ml
6 ml
B
500 ml
499.5 ml
16 ml
Two machines fill bottles that should hold 500 ml. Machine A filled eight bottles with 498, 502, 501, 499, 500, 503, 497 and 500 ml. Machine B gave 495, 506, 499, 508, 492, 500, 504 and 496 ml. Both means are 500 ml (4000 ÷ 8). The range for A is 503 − 497 = 6 ml and for B is 508 − 492 = 16 ml. The means are equal, so on average both machines are right, but machine A is much more consistent. A shop that wants every bottle to be close to 500 ml should choose machine A.
Day
1
2
3
4
5
6
Wait (min)
8
9
7
9
10
45
Waiting times in minutes at a clinic on six days: 8, 9, 7, 9, 10, 45. The mean is 88 ÷ 6 ≈ 14.7 minutes. The median is the mean of the 3rd and 4th ordered values (9 and 9), which is 9 minutes. The mode is 9. One day (45 minutes) was very unusual and has pulled the mean up. The median, 9 minutes, describes a typical day better than the mean does.
Archer
Mean
Median
Range
P
83
86.5
30
Q
81.75
81.5
6
Two archers each shot eight rounds. Archer P scored 78, 92, 65, 88, 95, 70, 85, 91 (mean 83, median 86.5, range 30). Archer Q scored 80, 82, 79, 84, 81, 83, 80, 85 (mean 81.75, median 81.5, range 6). P has the higher mean and median, so P scores more points on average. Q has the much smaller range, so Q is far more consistent. For a team where one very low score loses the match, a coach would choose Q; for a contest where only the best single score matters, P could be better.
Class activity
Dice duel. Roll two dice 10 times each, and score the number of the larger die each time. Each player records their 10 scores and finds the mean, median and range. Then play again with a rule that changes the result, such as taking the smaller die. Compare the averages and ranges and say how the rule changes them.
Practice
1
Delivery times in days from two shops, over 7 orders. Shop A: 3, 2, 4, 3, 3, 5, 2. Shop B: 1, 6, 1, 7, 1, 3, 3. Work out all four statistics for each shop, and say which shop you would choose if you need the parcel by a fixed date.
A: mean 22 ÷ 7 ≈ 3.1, median 3, mode 3, range 3. B: mean 22 ÷ 7 ≈ 3.1, median 3, mode 1, range 6. The averages are very similar, but A has the smaller range. For a fixed date choose A, because its delivery times are more consistent.
2
Write down two sets of five numbers that both have mean 20, where one has range 4 and the other has range 14. Explain what the different ranges tell you.
For example 18, 19, 20, 21, 22 (range 4) and 13, 17, 20, 23, 27 (range 14); both sums are 100. The set with range 4 is more consistent; the values are close to the mean. The set with range 14 is more spread out.
3
Prices in thousands of dollars of seven houses on a street: 210, 225, 230, 215, 220, 235, 640. Find the mean and the median. Which is a better description of a typical house on the street? Why?
Mean = 1975 ÷ 7 ≈ 282; median = 225 (the 4th ordered value). The price 640 is an extreme value that raises the mean, so the median is a better description of a typical house.
4
Bus route 7 has mean delay 6.2 minutes, median 5, mode 4 and range 14. Route 12 has mean delay 6.5, median 6, mode 6 and range 5. Write three sentences comparing the routes, and say which is more reliable.
Route
Mean
Median
Mode
Range
7
6.2
5
4
14
12
6.5
6
6
5
Route 7 has the lower mean and median delay, so on average it is slightly better. Route 12 has the much smaller range (5 against 14), so its delays are more consistent. Route 12 is more reliable, since you know roughly how late it will be; route 7 sometimes has very long delays.