GoalCompare groups of different sizes by writing each as a percentage, and explain why the overall percentage is not just the mean of two percentages.
New words
proportion · the part compared with the whole, often written as a fraction or percentagepercentage point · the unit for the difference between two percentages, so 80% and 75% are 5 percentage points aparttwo-way table · a table that sorts the same people or objects by two things at once
Explanation
If two groups have different sizes, the plain numbers are hard to compare. Change each to a percentage: divide the part by the whole, then multiply by 100. The group with the larger percentage has the larger proportion. If both percentages round to the same whole number, work to one decimal place. The gap between two percentages is given in percentage points. In a two-way table, find the percentage for each row separately. To find the percentage for everybody, add the groups first. The overall percentage lies between the two percentages, but it is usually not halfway, because the groups may have different sizes.
Germinated
Did not
Total
Percentage
Tray 1
42
14
56
75%
Tray 2
63
27
90
70%
Worked examples
Gardener
Germinated
Planted
Percentage
Zara
42
56
75%
Idris
63
90
70%
Zara plants 56 seeds and 42 germinate. Idris plants 90 seeds and 63 germinate. Who has the better germination rate? Zara: 42 ÷ 56 = 0.75 = 75%. Idris: 63 ÷ 90 = 0.70 = 70%. Zara is better, by 5 percentage points.
Swim
Do not swim
Total
Juniors
48
12
60
Seniors
36
84
120
All
84
96
180
A swimming club has juniors and seniors. Find the percentage in each group who swim, then the percentage for the whole club. Juniors: 48 ÷ 60 = 80%. Seniors: 36 ÷ 120 = 30%. Whole club: 84 ÷ 180 = 46.7% to 1 decimal place. This is not halfway between 80% and 30% (which would be 55%), because there are twice as many seniors.
Which is greater, 17 out of 25 or 41 out of 60? 17 ÷ 25 = 68%. 41 ÷ 60 = 68.3% to 1 decimal place. To the nearest whole number both are 68%, so one decimal place is needed. 41 out of 60 is slightly greater.
Class activity
Shoot-out. Make a paper ball and a bin. Do 20 throws and count the hits. Then your partner does 30 throws. Whose hit rate is better? Write each as a percentage, and then work out the percentage for the two of you together.
Practice
1
Bakery P baked 120 loaves and sold 84. Bakery Q baked 150 loaves and sold 117. Which sold the larger proportion, and by how many percentage points?
P sold 84 ÷ 120 = 70%. Q sold 117 ÷ 150 = 78%. Q sold the larger proportion, by 8 percentage points.
2
In a survey, 66 of 120 people under 30 travel by bus, and 52 of 200 people aged 30 or over travel by bus. Work out the percentage for each age group and for everyone, to 1 decimal place.
Under 30: 55%. Aged 30 or over: 26%. Everyone: 118 ÷ 320 = 36.9%.
3
Petra says: ‘School A had 90 absences and school B had 60, so school B has better attendance.’ School A has 1500 students and school B has 800. Is Petra right? Explain.
No. A: 90 ÷ 1500 = 6%. B: 60 ÷ 800 = 7.5%. A smaller percentage of school A was absent, so A has the better attendance. Petra compared the numbers, not the proportions.
4
A shop has 160 shirts and 25% are red. It also has 240 pairs of trousers and 45% are red. What percentage of all 400 items are red?
Red shirts: 40. Red trousers: 108. Total red: 148. 148 ÷ 400 = 37%.