If only we had …
To criticise, or to show regret about the past, say should have or ought to have, followed by a past participle: ‘We should have planted more trees.’ For a mistake, say shouldn’t have. Use could have + past participle for a possibility in the past that did not happen: ‘He could have walked, but he took the car.’ Use might have + past participle when you guess that something was possible: ‘The river might have been polluted by the factory.’ Do not use these forms for advice about now: say ‘You should recycle this’, not ‘should have’. In a debate, listen for inconsistencies: two ideas that cannot both be true.
| form | meaning | example |
|---|---|---|
| should have / ought to have | criticism or regret | We should have listened to the experts. |
| shouldn’t have | it was a mistake | You shouldn’t have thrown that paper away. |
| could have | possible, but did not happen | He could have walked to school. |
| might have | perhaps it happened | She might have forgotten the key. |
Amir, you are worried about the air near your school. Why?
We should have planted trees along the road years ago. This morning the drivers could have parked in the side street, but they waited outside the gate with their engines running, and the air smelled terrible.
Our town has the cleanest air in the country, so pollution is not a problem here. Of course, on most mornings you can hardly see the end of the street because of the traffic fumes, but we are doing our best.
Mr Lindqvist, some people say the council ought to have listened to the parents earlier. What is your answer?
| what was said | what was said later | inconsistent? |
|---|---|---|
| Our town has the cleanest air in the country. | You can hardly see the end of the street because of the fumes. | yes: that suggests the air is polluted |
| We should have planted trees along the road. | Trees would have helped to clean the air. | no: the ideas agree |
You should have asked me.
She might have missed the bus.
We could have gone by bicycle.
They shouldn’t have cut down the old trees.
Mini debate. Work in groups of four: a presenter, two students and a councillor. The topic is a problem in your town, such as litter in the park. The students use ‘should have’ and ‘could have’ to say what went wrong. The councillor answers, and the presenter listens for an inconsistency. Afterwards, tell the class what the presenter noticed.