Why the sine rule is not enough and the cosine rule a² = b² + c² − 2bc cos A (with the proof from Pythagoras), and finding a side from two sides and the included angle
Suppose two sides are 3 and 4 and the angle between them changes. At 90° the third side is 5 (Pythagoras). At 60° it is shorter, a² = 13; at 120° it is longer, a² = 37. The sine rule cannot start here: it needs a side and its opposite angle, and we know neither pair. The cosine rule fills the gap. Proof: in triangle ABC drop the height CD onto AB. In the right triangle ACD, AD = b cos A and CD = b sin A. Then BD = c − b cos A and, by Pythagoras in the right triangle BCD, a² = CD² + BD² = b² sin² A + (c − b cos A)² = b² sin² A + c² − 2bc cos A + b² cos² A = b² + c² − 2bc cos A, because sin² A + cos² A = 1. The other forms follow by renaming: b² = c² + a² − 2ca cos B and c² = a² + b² − 2ab cos C. The angle in cos is always the one opposite the side on the left. Example: b = 18 m, c = 22 m, A = 38° (a school kite string and its anchor). Then a² = 324 + 484 − 792 cos 38° ≈ 183.9 and a ≈ 13.6 m. For an obtuse angle cos A is negative, so −2bc cos A adds to the sum and a is larger than the Pythagoras value.
| Angle between 3 and 4 | 60° | 90° | 120° |
|---|---|---|---|
| a² | 13 | 25 | 37 |
| compare with 5 | a < 5 | a = 5 | a > 5 |
With a ruler and a protractor draw sides 3 cm and 4 cm with 60° between them. Measure the third side and compare with the square root of 13, about 3.6.