Many people believe that the number of private cars in city centres should be reduced.
To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.
Write at least 250 words.
This is an agree/disagree (opinion) question: the examiner expects one clear position, kept consistent from the introduction to the conclusion, with reasons and examples. The four answers take the same position but develop it very differently.
These answers and their bands are written and estimated by Darslab to show what changes from band to band. They are not official IELTS marks. Read the answer first, try to guess the band, then read the comments. The lesson Essay structure teaches the skill step by step.
Nowadays many cities have a lot of cars in the centre. In my opinion I agree with this idea because cars make many problems for the people who live in the city.
Firstly, cars make air pollution. When there are many cars in the centre, the air is very dirty and people are breathing bad air. This is bad for health, especially for old people and children. Also many people have problem with their lungs because of this. If the government reduce the cars, the air will be more clean.
Secondly, there is a big traffic. In the morning and in the evening people spend much time in the traffic jam. For example in my city Tashkent the roads in the centre is always full of cars and the people are late to work. Also the noise is very big and it is not good for people also. If there are less cars, the people can go to work faster.
However, some people say that they need the car because it is comfortable. They can go everywhere when they want. Also some people have a work what need a car, for example taxi driver. This is true but I think the public transport is more better than the private car.
Moreover, the government can build more metro and buses and the price must be cheap. Then the people will don't need to use their cars. Also the city centre will be more beautiful and safe for walking.
In conclusion, I agree that private cars should be reduced in the city centre because of pollution and traffic. The government must do something about this problem and make better public transport for people.
| Criterion | Band | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Task Response | 5 | The position is clear (âI agreeâ), but ideas stay simple and general, and the opposing view (âthey need the car because it is comfortableâ) is dismissed in one sentence. The Tashkent example is short and not developed. |
| Coherence and Cohesion | 5 | Paragraphs exist, but linking is repetitive and mechanical: âAlsoâ starts or appears in many sentences, and âMoreoverâ adds a point without a real connection. Some references are unclear (âthis problemâ). |
| Lexical Resource | 5 | Vocabulary is basic and repeated (âproblemsâ, âpeopleâ, âbigâ), with word-choice errors such as âmake air pollutionâ, âa big trafficâ and âa work what need a carâ. |
| Grammatical Range and Accuracy | 5 | Mostly simple sentences. Frequent errors in agreement and word forms (âthe roads ⊠isâ, âmore cleanâ, âmore betterâ, âwill donât needâ, âthe government reduceâ), though the meaning is usually clear. |
In short: This answer states an opinion and has paragraphs, but ideas are thin, linking is repetitive and there are frequent grammar and word-choice errors. It is a typical band 5.
In many large cities the centre is crowded with private cars. I largely agree that their number should be reduced, although I think this must be done carefully.
The main reason for reducing cars is the damage they cause to the environment. Vehicles produce exhaust gases which pollute the air, and this is harmful for the health of residents, especially children. In addition, traffic jams are a daily problem in city centres. For example, in my city it can take forty minutes to drive just five kilometres in the morning, so people waste time and money. If fewer cars would enter the centre, the streets would be quieter and cleaner.
Another advantage is that the space could be used in a better way. Car parks and wide roads take up a lot of land which could become parks or places for pedestrians. This would make the centre more pleasant for both residents and tourists.
On the other hand, there are some problems with this idea. Some people, such as elderly or disabled persons, depend on their cars because walking long distances is difficult for them. Also, shop owners may lose customers if people can not park near their shops. Therefore, a total ban would not be a good solution.
I think the government should introduce a charge for entering the centre by car, like in some European cities. The money from this charge could be spent for improving buses and metro lines, so people would have a real alternative. At the same time, special permits could be given to people who really need to drive.
To conclude, I agree that private cars should be reduced in city centres because of pollution, traffic and wasted space, but the authorities must provide good public transport and exceptions for people with special needs.
| Criterion | Band | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Task Response | 6 | All parts of the task are covered and the position is clear (âI largely agreeâ). Some ideas are underdeveloped: âwasted spaceâ and the charge for entering the centre are mentioned but not explained in detail. |
| Coherence and Cohesion | 6 | The structure is logical, with clear paragraphs, but linking words are somewhat mechanical (âIn additionâ, âOn the other handâ, âTo concludeâ) and sentences inside paragraphs are not always tightly connected. |
| Lexical Resource | 6 | Adequate range with some good items (âexhaust gasesâ, âpedestriansâ, âpermitsâ). Small errors appear in word choice and spelling, such as âcan notâ and âdisabled personsâ, and some repetition of âpeopleâ. |
| Grammatical Range and Accuracy | 6 | A mix of simple and complex sentences with conditionals and relative clauses. Errors are small and rarely stop understanding: âIf fewer cars would enter the centreâ (conditional), âspent for improving busesâ (preposition) and âharmful forâ. |
In short: This answer addresses every part of the question with relevant examples and a sensible structure, but development is uneven and the language is only adequate. It fits band 6.
In recent decades, the centres of many cities have become congested and polluted, and some governments have responded by restricting private vehicles. I strongly agree with this approach, provided that it is accompanied by realistic alternatives.
The most compelling argument for fewer cars is public health. Exhaust fumes contain fine particles that are linked to asthma and heart disease, and these are concentrated where traffic is heaviest. When a number of European cities introduced low-emission zones, air quality improved noticeably within few years. Reducing cars in the centre would therefore protect the people who live and work there, particularly children and the elderly.
A second benefit concerns the way urban space is used. Roads and car parks occupy a large proportion of the land in a typical centre, yet each car usually carries only one person. If this space were converted into pedestrian streets, cycle lanes and small parks, the city would become more attractive and economically active, since people tend to spend more time, and money, in places where it is pleasant to walk.
Admittedly, critics argue that such policies are unfair to those who cannot easily use public transport, such as disabled passengers, and that businesses depend on customers who arrive by car. These concerns are valid, but they can be addressed. Exemptions could be granted to residents with mobility problems, and delivery vehicles could be allowed to enter at fixed times. Moreover, shops in car-free areas often report higher sales because of the increase of foot traffic.
The key condition for success is investment in public transport. If buses, trams and metro lines are frequent, affordable and safe, most commuters will willingly leave their cars at home. A charge for entering the centre could finance these improvements.
In conclusion, limiting private cars in city centres brings clear benefits for health and for the quality of urban life, and the disadvantages can be reduced through careful planning and good alternatives.
| Criterion | Band | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Task Response | 7 | The position is clear and sustained (âI strongly agree ⊠provided thatâŠâ). Main ideas are extended with reasons and a concrete example (low-emission zones), and counter-arguments are addressed with solutions. |
| Coherence and Cohesion | 7 | Information is logically organised and each paragraph has a clear central topic. A good range of devices (âAdmittedlyâ, âMoreoverâ, âThe key conditionâ) is used, with only slight over-use of simple openers. |
| Lexical Resource | 7 | Some less common items are used with control (âcongestedâ, âlow-emission zonesâ, âeconomically activeâ, âfoot trafficâ). Collocations are mostly natural, with minor imprecision such as âfine particles that are linked toâ. |
| Grammatical Range and Accuracy | 7 | A variety of complex structures (conditionals, relative clauses, âprovided thatâ) and many error-free sentences. A few slips remain: âwithin few yearsâ (missing âaâ) and âincrease of foot trafficâ (preposition). |
In short: This answer has a clear position, well-developed paragraphs and a good range of language. Ideas are less sophisticated and vocabulary less precise than at band 8, so it is a solid band 7.
Few urban problems are as visible as the endless queues of cars crawling through city centres. Although restricting private vehicles can be politically unpopular, I firmly believe that doing so is both desirable and, with proper planning, entirely practicable.
The strongest justification is the toll that traffic takes on public health. Exhaust emissions are a major source of the fine particles that aggravate respiratory illness, and they build up precisely where people gather most densely. Cities that have introduced low-emission zones have generally recorded cleaner air within a few years, which suggests that even moderate restrictions can yield tangible results. Reduced noise and fewer road accidents are further, often overlooked, benefits.
Equally important is the question of how scarce central land should be used. A parked car occupies several square metres for most of the day while typically carrying a single occupant. Reallocating that space to wider pavements, cycle lanes and public squares would make a centre far more inviting, and there is evidence that pedestrians linger longer, and therefore spend more, in such surroundings than drivers who are merely passing through.
Opponents raise two main objections. The first is that restrictions penalise people with limited mobility; the second is that traders will lose custom. Neither is insurmountable. Exemptions for disabled residents and scheduled access for delivery vehicles would resolve the former, while the latter is contradicted by numerous cases in which shops in newly pedestrianised streets enjoyed higher turnover.
What ultimately determines success, however, is the quality of the alternatives. Drivers will abandon their cars only if trams, buses and metro services are frequent, affordable and reliable, so revenue from congestion charges should be ring-fenced for exactly that purpose.
In conclusion, curbing private cars in city centres would deliver healthier, quieter and more vibrant urban areas, and the legitimate concerns of vulnerable residents and businesses can be met through well-designed exemptions and sustained investment in public transport.
| Criterion | Band | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Task Response | 8 | All parts are fully answered with a clear, consistent position (âI firmly believeâ). Ideas are fully extended, relevant and supported by logical reasoning, and both objections are answered point by point. |
| Coherence and Cohesion | 8 | Skilful and natural cohesion: references (âthe former ⊠the latterâ), progression (âEqually importantâ, âWhat ultimately determines success, howeverâ) and paragraphing flow without mechanical linking. |
| Lexical Resource | 8 | A wide range used fluently and precisely: âaggravate respiratory illnessâ, âinsurmountableâ, âring-fencedâ, ânewly pedestrianised streetsâ. Collocations are natural, with only very rare awkwardness. |
| Grammatical Range and Accuracy | 8 | Wide range used flexibly and accurately: âAlthough ⊠can be politically unpopular, I firmly believe thatâŠâ, âThe first is thatâŠ; the second is thatâŠâ, passives (âis contradictedâ, âbe ring-fencedâ) and âonly ifâ conditionals. No errors found; the great majority of sentences are fluent and precise. |
In short: This answer develops every idea fully, links them skilfully and uses precise, natural language with almost no errors. It is a strong band 8.
Write your own answer to this question in 40 minutes (Task 2) or 20 minutes (Task 1), then compare it with the samples: which band does yours look like, and which âhow to move upâ point would improve it most?
IELTS is jointly owned by the British Council, IDP: IELTS Australia and Cambridge University Press & Assessment, which are not affiliated with, and do not endorse, Darslab. All Darslab questions, texts and model answers are original.