AdvertisementYour brand could be hereYour brand hereOn every Darslab page · students, parents and teachersinfo@darslab.comAsk for pricesPricesinfo@darslab.com

Discussion essay: homework for school children: band 5, 6, 7 and 8 answers

IELTS Writing Task 2 · Band 5 Band 6 Band 7 Band 8
The question

Some people believe that school children should be given homework every day. Others think that children should have free time after school instead.

Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.

Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.

Write at least 250 words.

This is a discussion question: the examiner expects both views to be explained fairly and a clear opinion of your own. The four answers show how the same balanced position can be developed at different levels.

These answers and their bands are written and estimated by Darslab to show what changes from band to band. They are not official IELTS marks. Read the answer first, try to guess the band, then read the comments. The lesson Essay structure teaches the skill step by step.

Band 5 sample answer

276 words · Darslab’s estimate: average 5.13 → band 5

People have different opinions about homework. Some people think that children must have homework every day and other people think children need free time. I will discuss both views and give my opinion.

On the one hand, homework is useful for the children. When children do homework they repeat the lesson which they learned at school, so they remember it better. For example, in math the children must practise many times, if not they forget. Also homework teach children to be responsible and to work alone without a teacher. Parents also can see what their child is studing in the school.

On the other hand, children need a free time too. After six or seven hours at school they are very tired and they want to play or meet with friends. If they have much homework, they have no time for sport and hobbies. This is bad for their health, because they sit all the time and some children is stressed. Also children who don't sleep enough can not study good on the next day.

In my opinion, I think that homework is necessary but it must be not too much. Teachers should give a small homework, for example thirty minutes, and not every day. Then the children will have time to rest and also to learn. In my country many teachers give very big homework and parents must help the children, but not all parents have time or knowledge.

In conclusion, there are advantages and disadvantages of homework. I think the best way is the balance between homework and free time, and teachers should think about this when they give the tasks to the pupils.

CriterionBandWhy
Task Response5.5Both views and an opinion are present, but each view gets only general points (“they remember it better”, “they are very tired”). The opinion is repeated rather than developed, and the example about teachers in “my country” is vague.
Coherence and Cohesion5There is a clear four-part structure, but linking is basic and repetitive (“On the one hand 
 On the other hand”, “Also” four times). Some sentences are only loosely connected to the point of the paragraph.
Lexical Resource5Limited range with repeated words (“homework”, “children”, “time”) and errors in word choice and spelling: “studing”, “study good”, “a free time”, “a small homework”.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy5Mostly simple sentences with frequent errors: “homework teach”, “some children is stressed”, “can not study good”, “must be not too much”. The errors sometimes make the sentence harder to follow.

In short: This answer discusses both views and gives an opinion, but ideas are limited and the language is basic with frequent mistakes. It is a typical band 5.

How to move up

  1. Develop each view with one clear reason and one example (for example, how daily revision helps in maths, or what a tired child cannot do after school) instead of listing short statements.
  2. Fix repeated basic errors: subject–verb agreement (“homework teaches”), countable and uncountable nouns (“some homework”, not “a small homework”), and “well” instead of “good”.
  3. Use a wider range of linkers and vocabulary (Furthermore, As a result, revise, stressful, balance) in place of repeating “also” and “children”.

Band 6 sample answer

315 words · Darslab’s estimate: average 6.00 → band 6

Homework has always been a part of school life, but people disagree about how much children should do. Some believe that daily homework is essential, whereas others argue that pupils need time to relax after school. In this essay I will discuss both opinions before explaining my own.

Those who support daily homework say that it helps children to revise what they have learnt in class. Without a regular practice, pupils often forget the new information, especially in subjects like mathematics and foreign languages. In addition, homework teaches children to organise their time and work independently, which are important skills for their future studies and careers.

However, there are also strong arguments against giving homework every day. Children already spend six or seven hours at school, and they are tired when they come home. If they must spend several more hours at their desks, they have no chance to do sports, play with friends or develop hobbies. This can cause stress and even health problems, such as lack of sleep. Some teachers also notice that too much homework make children dislike learning.

In my opinion, a balance is the best solution. I believe that homework is useful, but it should be short and given only on some days of the week. For example, teachers could give twenty or thirty minutes of work in weekdays and leave the weekends free. The tasks should be interesting, for example projects or reading, instead of copying the same exercises many times.

Another point is that not every family can help children with their tasks. Parents who work long hours may not have enough time, so schools should organise a place where pupils can do homework with a teacher.

To sum up, although daily homework has some benefits, children also need free time to rest and enjoy their childhood. Therefore, I think teachers should give a moderate amount of homework.

CriterionBandWhy
Task Response6Both views are discussed and the opinion (“a balance is the best solution”) is clear and relevant. Some points, such as the suggestion that tasks should be projects or reading, are mentioned but not explained.
Coherence and Cohesion6.5Organisation is clear, with a logical order and signposting (“However”, “In my opinion”, “To sum up”). Links inside paragraphs are sometimes mechanical, but the answer is easy to follow.
Lexical Resource6Adequate vocabulary with some good items (“revise”, “independently”, “moderate amount”). Some repetition (“homework” many times) and small imprecisions such as “spend several more hours at their desks” and “have no chance to do sports”.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy5.5A mix of simple and complex sentences with some accurate conditionals and relative clauses. Errors rarely impede meaning: “Without a regular practice”, “the new information”, “work in weekdays”, “too much homework make children”.

In short: This answer covers both views and the writer’s opinion with sensible ideas and a clear structure. Development, vocabulary and grammatical range are adequate rather than wide, which makes it a band 6.

How to move up

  1. Extend one point from each side with a concrete example, such as a named subject and what happens when pupils do not practise.
  2. Use more varied vocabulary to avoid repeating “homework” and “children” (assignments, pupils, tasks, learners) and choose more natural collocations (“no opportunity to play sport”).
  3. Add more complex structures with accurate punctuation, for example participle clauses (“Having spent six hours at school, children 
”) and relative clauses with commas.

Band 7 sample answer

319 words · Darslab’s estimate: average 7.00 → band 7

Whether pupils should receive homework every day is a question that divides teachers, parents and educators alike. While daily tasks can reinforce learning, I believe that children benefit more from a moderate approach that leaves them with genuine free time.

Supporters of daily homework make two main points. First, regular practice helps pupils to consolidate what they have studied, particularly in subjects such as mathematics and languages where skills improve through repetition. Second, completing tasks on their own teaches children to plan their time and take responsibility for their learning, habits that will serve them at the university and in the workplace. Parents also gain a clear picture of what their children are studying.

Nevertheless, the opposing view deserves serious consideration. After a long school day, many children are mentally exhausted, and extra work in the evening can reduce the time available for exercise, family meals and sleep. Over time, this may lead to stress and a loss of motivation, which is the opposite of what homework is meant to achieve. In addition, play and hobbies develop creativity and social skills that cannot be learnt from a textbook.

In my view, the quality of homework matters far more than its quantity. Short, well-designed tasks, such as a reading assignment or a small project, are likely to be more effective than long lists of repetitive exercises. I would therefore recommend homework on three or four days a week, lasting no more than thirty to forty-five minutes for primary pupils, with weekends kept free.

It is also worth to remember that families differ in the support they can offer. Children whose parents are busy or have little education may struggle with difficult tasks, so schools should provide supervised study sessions after lessons.

In conclusion, although daily homework has some advantages, a balanced system that combines limited, meaningful tasks with ample free time is likely to produce healthier and more motivated learners.

CriterionBandWhy
Task Response7Both views are presented with developed arguments and the opinion is clear throughout (“a moderate approach”). Ideas are supported with sensible reasons, although the equity paragraph is slightly shorter than the others.
Coherence and Cohesion7Clear overall progression and good paragraphing, with a range of linkers (“Nevertheless”, “In addition”, “It is also worth to remember”). Some openings (“First 
 Second 
”) are fairly predictable.
Lexical Resource7.5Good range with some less common items used appropriately (“consolidate”, “reinforce”, “mentally exhausted”, “supervised study sessions”). There are a few small imprecisions of collocation.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy6.5A variety of complex structures (“Whether pupils should 
 is a question that
”, relative and participle clauses) with frequent error-free sentences. A few slips remain: “worth to remember”, “at the university”, and a repeated “are likely to be” pattern.

In short: This answer discusses both views fully, states a clear opinion and uses a good range of language with few errors. The ideas and style are not as precise or sophisticated as at band 8, so it is a band 7.

How to move up

  1. Add a specific example to the argument about quality, such as describing one sample homework project for primary pupils and what it teaches.
  2. Vary the structure of sentences further, with more inversion or subordinate clauses, to avoid repeated patterns like “X is likely to be 
”.
  3. Replace some general phrases (“a clear picture”, “serious consideration”) with more precise language and correct small slips such as “worth to remember” (worth remembering) and “at the university”.

Band 8 sample answer

324 words · Darslab’s estimate: average 7.88 → band 8

Few topics in education generate as much debate as homework. Advocates of daily assignments emphasise discipline and revision, whereas critics worry about children's wellbeing. Although both positions have merit, I believe the most effective approach is a moderate and carefully designed one.

Those in favour of daily homework generally argue that learning is consolidated through repetition. A pupil who practises new vocabulary or mathematical methods each evening is more likely to retain them than one who revises only before an examination. Furthermore, working unsupervised cultivates self-discipline and time management, qualities that become indispensable in higher education and employment. Homework also offers parents a window into the curriculum, allowing them to support their children's progress.

Conversely, opponents contend that a school day of six or seven hours is already demanding, and that additional evening work erodes the time children need for rest, physical activity and unstructured play. Persistent fatigue and pressure can foster anxiety and resentment towards study, defeating the very purpose of the exercise. Moreover, free time is not idle time: hobbies, sport and friendships nurture creativity, teamwork and emotional resilience, none of which are easily taught in a classroom.

On balance, I consider the quality of homework far more important than its frequency. Brief, purposeful tasks, such as reading a chapter, interviewing a relative or completing a short problem set, tend to be more beneficial than lengthy, repetitive worksheets. I would therefore suggest assignments on some weekdays only, limited to around half an hour for younger pupils, with weekends largely free.

A further consideration is equity. Pupils from households where parents are working long hours or lack the necessary education may be disadvantaged by demanding tasks, so schools should offer supervised study periods so that every child can complete their work on equal terms.

In conclusion, daily homework offers real academic benefits but at a potential cost to wellbeing; a balanced system of purposeful, limited tasks is the best way to secure both.

CriterionBandWhy
Task Response8Both views are fully developed and balanced, and the opinion is clear and consistent. Ideas are extended with logical reasons, including the original point about equity between families.
Coherence and Cohesion8Cohesion is skilful: ideas progress naturally with signposting (“Conversely”, “On balance”, “A further consideration”) and clear referencing (“the very purpose of the exercise”). Paragraphs are sequenced logically.
Lexical Resource8A wide range of natural, precise vocabulary (“cultivates self-discipline”, “erodes the time”, “unstructured play”, “emotional resilience”, “equity”). Rare, minor lapses of style only.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy7.5Wide range used flexibly: concessive “Although both positions have merit
”, the substitute “one” in “more likely to retain them than one who revises only before an examination”, a participle (“defeating the very purpose”), “none of which are easily taught” and a long “so that” clause in the equity paragraph. Almost all sentences are error-free; the only weaknesses are the heavy length of that last sentence and the formal “none 
 are” (strictly “is”).

In short: This answer is fully developed, skilfully organised and written in precise, natural English with very few errors. It is a strong band 8.

How to move up

  1. To approach band 9, support the opinion with one concrete illustration, for example a brief case of a school that reduced homework, integrated into the argument.
  2. Make the writer’s own voice more prominent in the second half, using evaluation phrases that weigh the two sides more explicitly.
  3. Check final polish: shorten the long equity sentence, consider “none of which is easily taught”, and vary repeated patterns such as “tend to be more beneficial than”.

Now write your own

Write your own answer to this question in 40 minutes (Task 2) or 20 minutes (Task 1), then compare it with the samples: which band does yours look like, and which “how to move up” point would improve it most?

IELTS is jointly owned by the British Council, IDP: IELTS Australia and Cambridge University Press & Assessment, which are not affiliated with, and do not endorse, Darslab. All Darslab questions, texts and model answers are original.